7 Year old "Karate Masters" is not a possibility! Its delusional thinking

7 Year old "Karate Masters" is not a possibility! Its delusional thinking

Mastery.jpg

 

A recent video of a 7 year old  “karate Master” has been making rounds. A friend posted it, another sent me a link and then a student sent me the same link. My student’s note also said how amazed and envious he was of this “young master.”  I decided to engage, and either be educated or perhaps shed light on the subject of mastery.

My flight was delayed a few hours, so wanted to invest this time wisely. Made a few phone calls and finally called my student who sent me the link. And after the usual pleasantries we got into the 7 year old karate master.

“She is so impressive Sensei, makes me very envious” he exclaimed with true admiration in his voice and he continued “don’t you think she is great?”

I paused for a second as the line at the airport Jamba Juice inched forward “What I think is that people posting this nonsense at best are doing the kid and the arts a great disservice and are grossly misinformed, and at worst are sheer liars.“  A few heads in the line turned trying to access what’s going on. I smiled and waited for a response.

“What? You mean to say she is not good? Look at her kiai and the picture perfect kicks. Sensei, perhaps you are being too harsh.”

 “Does she look impressive – Yes! Does she understand what she is doing – I highly doubt it. And is she displaying mastery – Absolutely NOT.  What I am saying is you are mixing a good performance of some coordinated moves – in this case a Kata (could have been a dance) with mastery.”  I said, and continued looking at the options at Jamba Juice somewhat amazed at how mainstream juicing seems to have become, They have at least 10 juices (not smoothies) though quite expensive.

“hmmm, I don’t know Sensei, it still looks like she has mastered those sidekicks which are my big struggle. Look at how her leg snaps in and stays in the air” he continued to idolize her form.

“Her form looks good, no doubt, but is it functional?”

“She is too young to test it out Sensei, if that’s what you mean.”

It was painful waiting behind this blonde as she wanted all details of the in/organic, sugar content, juice v/s smoothie details from the young cashier.  I was grateful to be having this conversation to keep my calm, “So what she has doing is a battle form, passed down as crystallization from an old master. And while she seems to appear all powerful doing it, does she have the understanding and strength to make it functional? I would say NO!”

“But she looks powerful and would be a great ambassador for martial arts, I think” he said hesitantly.

“Maybe or maybe not, just because she looks good does not meant she should have the center stage” and as I sad this, the blonde turned around and gave me a look. I smile and continue my conversation “looking good should not be the reason one should be given the center stage. This only makes them feel entitled, and is the absence of humility. True humility is also the hallmark of mastery.” And at this the blonde turns around and says “excuse me.” And then I realized she thought I was talking to her/about her, and told her, to take her time as I was enjoying my conversation with a friend.  I could tell she was not used to being ignored - She frowned and got back to taking her time to order the perfect juice or give the appearance of it.

“Let me ask you this question, would you say she stands a chance defending herself or transmit this knowledge to the next generation. Do you think she would be better ambassador as you say, to an art or someone like say my Sensei?” It was a trick question but wanted to get into the heart of the matter. I now paused, and looked at the Blonde girl ahead of me trying to decipher her decision strategy and let the pause work on the mind of the student. She turned around again; I smiled and asked if I could help her choose? She says no thank you and finally orders an orange juice. 10 minutes to get to an OJ.  I quickly ordered a green citrus juice for lunch, paid the $4 and get back to my call.

“So you want to study with her?” I continued

“Err no sensei, that’s not what I meant.” He protested

“I know, am messing with you but hoping that we both learn something in the process. She looks good doing a performance. But that’s not mastery. To me mastery is a lifelong striving, not a performance. Mastery is the ability to absorb, integrate, transform and transmit a particular intelligence. Here we are speaking about martial arts. So mastery is the ability to quickly ABSORB (learn the material), then INTEGRATE (meaning make it a part of your very being), TRANSFORM (bring your own expression of it, and have the knowledge change you as well) and finally have the ability to TRANSMIT (teach this to others elegantly) this martial knowledge. Mastery is the ability to keep shrinking this cycle with every new learning. That is MASTERY! You feel me?” and I walked and picked up my green juice, which magically showed up before the Orange Juice for the Blonde. She displayed her anger and asks the lady behind the counter why is her order not out yet even though she ordered before me. I could not contain myself, I blurted cheekily “Know what you want, go for it, and move on.” And I walked away to get back to my conversation on mastery and have my green lunch.

“I understand Sensei mastery is process and not a destination. And appearances can be deceiving.” I could hear him be precise in how he now communicated. He continued “How do you define mastery in when there are so many forms and so many expressions of the art Sensei? I tend to get lost in all the forms that exist, leave alone know who true masters are”

“Think about it this way – draw a two by two matrix. On the x axis have old and new, and on the y axis have form and function. So what you have is 4 boxes – old form, old function/application, new application and new form. Now you have people who have made religions of each of these our boxes, and see them as mutually exclusive. The old form people claim to preserve the way things were done for example during the 1500s. The old applications have found their niche is being the bunkai or applications experts. They tend to look for secrets in how the forms were applied back then; you will see this in the Dim Mak or Pressure point experts/seminar circuit. The new applications box is filled by personal combative experts who will help you draw your own best way to respond to situations. And the new style box is essentially a set of personal combative methods that are becoming established as a style.” I paused, and drank my juice as I checked the flight status. The flight was delayed another 2 hours. Oh well!

“I think I am following you Sensei, so there are 4 ways of doing MA, and you can have mastery in each box?” he enquired.

“No – to the contrary, these are four boxes to understand phases – though IMHO people overspecialize and get stuck in a stage. To me the old form box is about ABSORB the knowledge – be it a set of forms or ways of doing your strikes.  The next box of Old function/applications, one learns how those moves were used by old-time warrior or teachers. This is INTEGRATION of the knowledge, and as you gain proficiency in this, you start to make new connections. And your own genetics and personal learnings start to inform your own new interpretations – this takes you to the third box of New function. You find to ways to adapt and bring your unique expressions to the moves, styles etc – to me this is true TRANSFORMATION. Finally as your expression finds more ground, and people start wanting to learn how you do it – you begin to teach this and gain a small following. This is TRANSMITTING of your truth. A new way of doing things emerge. “

I walked around the airport to find a place to sit, and noticed quite a few people were getting agitated with the delayed flights. I found a quiet corner, booted my laptop. I wanted to give the student a few moments to absorb this and waited for him to say something. Things had begun to click for him, and he said “aha it makes sense – so you are saying that mastery is process, it’s almost cyclical. You may start in an old style like ours, and learn the applications. Over time I may find new ways of doing things based on the same principles. And then I share that with others, we might find a new style of doing things. So this is mastery – a whole cycle.”

“Yes, to me this is the cycle, and when the new findings infuse the old ways as well, the new ways becomes standardized. Think about JKD – Bruce Lee started this as a personal expression, over time it became a style of sorts, and now is almost a system. You tend to hear things like SIgung Bruce or Guro Inosanto does this etc. In other words, new becomes old and old becomes new. This is the cycle. All personal expressions that made sense /survived became systems. And new teachers came along infused old systems and created new styles. This will go on forever. “

 

Another 90 minutes before I fly to the Sin City. My old-time student was excited at learning this. And in this discussion I opened up new distinctions. To sum it up – true mastery for me is the ability to Absorb, Integrate, Transform and Transmit elegantly. And as mastery increases the time between absorb and transmit shrinks drastically. I signed off with the student, read a novel for a while until it was time to board the plane. Once boarded it was time to capture this conversation for some other students along the way. And the seat next to me was now to be occupied by the same Blonde who was agitated with me throughout. This will be an interesting flight! Enough, for today.

Verbal Aiki Over Coffee - A Personal Method of Finding Students who resonate with the Old Ways

Verbal Aiki Over Coffee - A Personal Method of Finding Students who resonate with the Old Ways

Potential students find me or the dojo and always want to "talk over coffee" before they commit. I try to weed them out early so I meet them. They have the same questions usually and I politely answer things about style, rank, belts etc. Every so often, just like earlier this month a student wanted to know what i am capable of doing, as though it would be potentially transferred to them. And it also highlights a fundamental difference IMO about two differing approaches and modes of being. I would be curious to hear any/all thoughts on this.

But first a little context and typical conversation (this one happened earlier this month). What follows is about 20 minutes into the conversation after the usual questions have been answered, and he inquires about my own training regiment.

The potential student " You are a Sensei, so why do you still train with different people?" Me "Because I can and it keeps me humble" Him "Is it also because you are not confident in your skills?" Me "I would like to think I can handle myself, but one must constantly sharpen the blade." Him "Have you been in real fights? Does this stuff work?" Me "unfortunately yes I have had to fight many times, and have had my ass handed to me growing up. Not easy being small, different and smart ass - trust me. When I could not take the beatings anymore I started training hard." Him "but have you used your training to fight and beat them up?" Me "who is them? And the purpose of the training is arriving at a place where you dont have to fight but if you ever need to then you have some skills." Him "so you have used your training, tell me more about it pls" Me "what is there to know, i am here in one piece, thats all there is to it." Him "I dont understand, what did you do? how was the fight?" Me "The outcome is I am here, and for the how - well you got to train for that and pay the price" Him "I dont understand what I will be able to do if you dont tell me" Me "I dont know what you can do and more importantly should do, unless I see you train consistently." Him "This is not going anywhere" Me "Where do you want it to go?" Him " I want to know in how many ways will I be able to kick someones ass if I train with you" Me "you just need to do it one way well, and besides thats not what its about for me" Him "Then what is it about" Me "Its about not having to ever fight" Him " What ? Then why go and train with different teachers and teach consistently" Me " One must embrace violence to be at peace, embrace it so you can transform it" Him " I am confused, why train if you dont want to fight" Me "I train in order to be at peace, and peace is the state of being. A state where fighting is NOT - atleast for me" him "I am still confused" Me " When you train hard enough, you become very conscious of the consequences of your skills, and are less prone to use them. This can become a deterrent for you and others. And the end result is usually peace. Heavens forbid, if a fight breaks out then the skills will kick in. Either way the result is still the same" Him " ok, so will I get hurt and be in pain if I train with you?" Me " Pain will become your friend, and yes you will have loads of it" Him "So I will be in pain no matter what.. weather I fight or not" Me "Well, yes thats one way of seeing things" Him "whats the difference?" Me "intention and consciousnesses" Him "I think Kenpo is better suited for me, but thank you for your time" Me "Yes I think so too, maybe we will see each other in a few years.." Him "To fight?" Me " Perhaps to fight the notion of fighting" Him "I am confused" Me "I know, enjoy the coffee and relish he Kenpo, it has some wonderful things to teach us all" Him "You are not going to tell me why your fighting is better than Kenpo?" Me " Styles are not better or worse, the practitioners are" Him "I dont understand" Me " Its ok, I speak funny sometimes. Enjoy the coffee"

My current student who listened in on the whole interaction laughed out loud and said "Sensei, you are chasing away prospective students" I responded "Am I? Or am I saving time for the students who are already paying the price? Besides there is such a fundamental difference between the students who truly want to learn and thosewho want to fight for the sake of fighting"

"What is the difference Sensei?" "Well those who want to truly learn seem to ask about the philosophy and transformations within themselves and those who want to fight ask about what changes they can do to their opponent. At this point I am interested in teaching the  former group. There are plenty of places that teach the latter. This is where I am right now. Ok lets train"

Different Paths, similar Sequences, Same Goal

Different Paths, similar Sequences, Same Goal



Sometime last year afraid of possibly offending me a senior student was being cautious on how to have this conversation. Sensing his
hesitation and the issue I asked him how his other training was going. He looked very surprised, The tension eased and he said good, and quickly was apologising. He added that he does not have any one else to train with and hence needs to do this. And then asked me "How did you know? Who told you Sensei?" I told him that his movements had changed, and I had adumbrated the hallmarks of another familiar system. I asked him to ease up "Its a free world, and you are allowed to go train when and where you want. I do not own you! No need to apologize. Besides, trying different things out is also the only way to know to which tune you move/dance the best. Choosing to cross train or training exclusively in another art does not negate our system of Aiki nor our teaching. In many ways its perhaps enhances what you do. And in the process if you do find something even better suited for your unique needs then good for you. Keep me informed of your discoveries." 

I told him about my own cross training in both Chinese Internal Martial Arts (CIMA) and Filipino Martial Arts (FMA). " I LOVE and TEACH Aikijujutsu, and the cross training has only added to my own understanding of Aiki. I am able to see both the problems and solutions in combat with a different sets of lenses. The cross training has served to make my study of Aiki even more conscientious and informed - esp the genius of Aiki In Yo Ho. This kind of cross training does not take away from any art, it infact increased my appreciation for them all. And more importantly pointed me towards a sequence of learning/being" - 

Step 1 - the pursuit of technique (Religion of Style) Step 2 - the pursuit of specific principle/s (Religion of SYstem) Step 3 - the pursuit of spontaneous response (Religion of self expression) Step 4 - the pursuit of generalized harmony (A state of religiousness, generalized principles and mirroring) Step 5 - Empty Mind

(I do draw a fundamental distinction between religion and religioussness. Religion ties you down to a set of beliefs and methods of interacting with those issues greater than yourself (including but not exclusively combat), whereas the state of religiousness is about embracing all the fragrances, commonality across all ways of knowing while interacting with that which is greater than self.In the context of martial arts religion is about adherence to a very strict interpretation of what can/cant be done, usually coming from a source outside of yourself - this IMHO usually blinds you to a LOT... Religiousness is this context is the ability to spontaneously respond to what ever emerges, and aligning oneself to whole - in a way that enhances everything everywhere. I can keep going on this but do not want to diagress...if the model/ling itself is of interest to you, ping me privately)

Fast forward a few months, An email from another senior student made me smile. IN a relaxed manner he started opening up about his effective application of Aiki Principles into his other training, and the beginnings of seeing the unity of the arts - based on generalized principles. And it makes me happy that in this sharing, and open acceptance has solidified not only our relationship, but  also pushing them towards that state of generalized harmony, and ultimately emptiness ... which are also my own pursuits at this time.

So this is specifically for two of the senior students working on other arts in addition ot KAR Aiki with me- go at it with all your heart, and explore them fully. This is perhaps one of the best ways to validate what you have learnt from me, refine your understanding and restructure what/how you do things that work for you. Cheers on your journey, you have not offended me, on the contrary am very proud that you have taken your growth seriously into your own hands.

You may/may not end up choosing a very different route, and means however I look forward to seeing the same horizon together, and hear stories from your journey to the same destination!

Mountain View Aiki - The Approach to Martial Study Defined

Mountain View Aiki - The Approach to Martial Study Defined

I frequently get questions on what the so called "MVAK approach" is all about. A recent semi-private conversation bought this to forefront, and I wanted to make this available to a wider audience of students and friends for thoughts.

A few senior students and I were having an in depth conversation on all things: Martial Arts, Life, Philosophy, and Individual Expression. One students spoke to me privately and said, “Sensei, the way you approach things has changed. I see the same things and yet... they are very different. What is the right way?”

I answered, matter of fact, “Well, which one works?” He looked confused for a second then said, “Both work Sensei." I responded, “Then they are both right are they not? Focus on what makes them both work, not the mere sight of them.” This student is particularly cerebral and thinks deeply about things. After a few minutes he nodded and said he wanted to learn the two "ways". As I demonstrated the the two "ways", I also brought in a 3rd and 4th "way" to do the exact same technique – the first variation of Irimi Nage/Entering Throw (the first throw one learns within the first month of training). 

I could see the sparks fly and confusion begin to set in…and of course this is the perfect ground for allowing true expression to emerge and an understanding of new principals. I saw the look in the student’s eye and I knew exactly what that meant. I have experienced the same bewilderment and magic with my own true teachers. For this is where true learning begins- I tread this ground very carefully and deliberately. ( I have learned from many teachers, but I only consider four of them as my true teachers- among them Sastri Sensei, my root/core/principal teacher)

“There is no 'one way' to do things, and extending that line, there is no one system or style with all the right answers...what remains constant through the whole process is YOU! Doesn't it make sense to learn how to access that YOU and its interaction with all pressures (combat or life) put on it. The systems you study give you tools to deal with life, however the system won’t solve the problem – YOU have to! Hence the focus is to expose you to Natural Principals. Those principals give rise to Natural Techniques that emerge from them, and those belong to YOU and only YOU.” 

I saw some heads shaking, and one student even looked puzzled. I turned to him and said, “No one will come fight your battles, YOU have to. These are a set of tools, but ultimately they have to be YOUR tools. If you align yourself with those natural principals, you don’t have to remember techniques, you will want the Right Response To Emerge. That is the game we are after. It just so happens we are using a system which is VERY good at dealing with many combat situations, however it (the system) won’t fight your fight, YOU have got to do it, YOU have to have the heart to jump in. I don’t care if you know 10,000 techniques and every variation to them... if you lack heart to apply them, to try them out in real life, then as far as I am concerned the techniques and time spent learning them are useless.”

I sensed a little frustration in another particular student- he likes things laid out in black and white, as a model that he can digest and “vomit back.” Nothing is wrong with that approach, but if you are learning with me from that approach, get familiar with frustration. As anticipated he asked, “Sensei – so what are we really doing here at MVAK ? Is this not KAR which has been handed down for generations?”

We had to come to this point, it’s a good, a valid question.“Yes what we do is KAR, and KAR is a particular approach to combat. I teach it almost exclusively BUT I also bring my own understandings from other fields of study, martial and otherwise- for if you follow natural principals, they will always be complementary to one another, not opposed. (Both of my KAR teachers talked about learning natural principals and applying that to what we do in the dojo, and in life.) Align with them, and do not fight against them. THAT's what we do to the extreme level. For the only thing constant in nature is change. The only thing that was constant, that IS constant in my training is change. I don’t know how many variations & techniques I have forgotten because every time I hit the mat with HRV or SS Sensei there was something new. And if you had studied for any length of time with both of them you would know exactly what I mean.”

“Therefore, techniques by themselves are not the endgame. What we have to focus on are the principals and process of learning. So you ask me what are we doing here at MVAK, let me be very succinct and clear about this," (I paused to get complete attention), “MVAK is not a static thing, it is a process, always growing towards mastery, striving and yet never arriving. We have learned the only thing constant in nature is CHANGE, so we aim to harness that and to be at home with that one constant. In other words I am interested in a Game called YOU and how YOU deal with what shows up. Techniques are just a starting point – the process of learning and unfolding is where the magic is and THAT is what MVAK is about. KAR provides me with the tools to do just that. Understand?”

They nodded and I concluded, “Where systems and well carved paths end, you begin to emerge! That’s the game I am after, and MVAK is the process of doing it, while we use the fantastic combat skills of KAR as tools on this journey.” With that we ended class.

Deep down, I know this, my approach, is NOT for everyone. Especially in this day and age where sound bites, 7 pre-defined steps to mastery, and quick fixes sell. What I offer is for those few who choose to become real Apprentices to power: Apprentices to a natural order, Apprentices to the process of unfolding, unlearning and, when required, unleashing the power of combat. THAT is what we are about. The Game is You, the rules are natural processes and the system(s) we study are the tools.

What the tools are for? If your answer is just combat (or, even worse, you say, well that is what was done 1000 years ago by some holy monk on the mountain) then it’s a very small game you are playing. 

My dojo is NOT the place for that small game. 

I am interested in the Big Game, and, paradoxically, becoming ever smaller in it. If you understand, if this calls you, we should talk. I'd rather take 10 students a 1000 miles into themselves than taking 1,000 students one mile down the road.

 

The Poetics of A Martial Education - Training Under Sastri Sensei

The Poetics of A Martial Education - Training Under Sastri Sensei

The Poetics[i] of A Martial Education

His knife sneakily came in from behind the shield hand, and made its way to my neck.  Instinctively, I rolled into the #6 taisabaki[ii], “adhering to the weapon hand” while moving the body to be “where the knife is not” and applied a lock on his arm. We both laughed as he then executed a rather elegant internal “turning palm change” and was out of the kansentsu waza, and thrust the knife with the other hand towards my belly. I slammed this knife hand while dropping my body weight to the ground: the “marriage to gravity[iii]” saved the day again.

We continued this for the next 45 minutes. Think of this as counter for counter[iv] and sticky weapons[v] put together.  He brings 25 odd years of training in Kuntao[vi] and Silat[vii] where I usually rely on my training in KAR Aikijujutsu. We ended our session as always with some green tea or chai/Indian Tea and discussions.

Whenever our schedules permit, my friend, a very high ranking member in another school, and I  enjoy comparing our concepts and techniques as well as figuring out solutions to the challenges posed by each other’s systems. We do this with the hope of discovering what works and what are the problem areas to work on. Over our chais he asked, “where did you learn those counters, I have never seen anyone do those things in my 25 years in martial arts!”

“From many places, however I predominantly credit my learning in KAR under Sastri Sensei and Vilaire Sensei for most of what you see me do plus some very personal expressions. And it was the time with Sastri Sensei in particular that opened my mind to what is possible and what one can accomplish. He put the art in the martial for me and he has always been more than a martial arts trainer to me- he is  a Sensei in the truest sense of the word.”

“It’s rare to find a true teacher of art. Tell me more, what was it like learning from Sastri Sensei?”

It’s a question I get often, and can’t answer often enough. Today I decided to try and unravel that question. “I don’t know where to start, it has always been intense. We trained 5-6 days a week in the heyday, and the learning went on for 90 minutes on the mat and equally long off the mat.”

We laughed as my friend added, “Same with my Master, these guys love to teach and talk, don’t they?”

I sipped the delicious ginger chai. “I think you and I are guilty of that now, yes, we do love to discuss and philosophize about the arts. Anyways training on the basics was constant, and we did many variations/henka to the same technique. Sensei would never do the same technique twice in a row. Initially it was overwhelming, until the pattern began to reveal itself, to emerge…and that pattern was natural principles.  The variations and escapes always blew me away and it was much later in the training that I realized that Sastri Sensei would slip in Menkyo, or as you would call Master, level techniques/concepts into our learning regularly. This only became obvious to me when the formal training in Menkyo began many years later, and many of the moves/counters were already self-evident.”

He was listening intently, fascinated with both KAR and my time with Sastri Sensei in particular. He too has trained in “the old ways” under a very well-known tough master. Since his graduation he has been exploring his own expression in the art. He continued, “but that can’t be it, it’s not just showing you advanced techniques early… what are you holding back?”

“Not holding back, I just don’t know how to frame it yet. The physical aspect is the easy part. If one sticks to it, most can at least imitate the moves and do it reasonably well. Sensei called that mode of learning Monkey See, Monkey Do.” We both laughed and continued sipping the tea. “However his greatest gift was opening the minds of those students who paid attention. To me, being with him was always about being cracked open to Wonder, Magick and Possibility. “

“Now we are getting somewhere Mahi, tell me about the opening of the mind. And how are you using the term mind – the somewhat limited western way or the more encompassing eastern way?”  He put his cup down, clasped his hands together and leaned in to listen with a sense of fierce curiosity.

I pondered a little, as sometimes English is a hard language for me to explain the more “subtle felt aspects” of the arts. “I think of those two minds as a continuum. Let me explain. Sastri Sensei introduced all of his students to NLP in the early 1990s. Not all followed, a few did while I completely embraced it, as evident even today. The brain based pursuit of elite performance was an eye opener. For the first time, I started making the transition from pure brawn, to thinking about things…even though it was at that time in pursuit of even more brawn.” We both laughed knowingly.

He jumped in, “You think about things? Surely you are mistaken.”

We continued laughing hard, and everyone in the café turned to look at two sweaty guys with sticks and knives on their sides, talking about weird things. I continued, “So I devoured the whole NLP thing, especially the modeling aspects of it, as I wanted to move like my Sensei did. And I would take diligent notes from his lessons and build mental models to test. This was the opening of the small mind – the brain, or the western mind as you say. However the real lessons were always about how we become better human beings. He demonstrated the path, with integrity and character. He is one of the most moral/ethical men I have the privilege of knowing.  When he said something, I knew he meant every word of it. And his love for the art, for his students and for his friends was unbounded. Neither money nor fame got in the way his martial arts.”

We almost had finished our chai, and ordered round two. I confessed, “you know, I f****d up quite a bit. In hindsight, my immature behavior back in the early days made enemies both in the dojo and outside. At one point I almost quit, primarily because of my ego. However, I owned up to my faults and apologized to him in person. He was compassionate and he warmly forgave and forgot everything. I must add, that I know there were times when he was angry at my behavior but he never once stopped teaching or leading by example.  This was the beginning of the opening to the bigger mind, the way we Easterners think about it.”

The next cup of chai was here, and the sweet smell of Darjeeling tea and ginger just warmed up the environment even more. My friend continued, “Yes, the bigger mind is all encompassing, and  the heart is the way. Western Science is just waking up to the wisdom of the heart – especially how it has its own grey matter if you will, and a decision center. You are familiar with the work of HeartMath[viii] of course. But, continue, I am curious about the training.”

As the sweet gingerly taste and rich conversation woke me up even more I continued, “yes that’s the bigger mind, opening of the heart. And what has to be learned is the courage to follow its impulses. I think that’s what most of the true meat is, it’s the place where training gives way to an education. Come one, if you are training for 20 odd years, it’s NOT to deal with a punch, lock, knife stab or a simple squabble. To walk on one’s path, to listen to one’s heart, and follow those impulses, (many of which may seem irrational) require courage. That ultimately is the training I believe he imparted on the handful who stuck through it.”

“ He laid the path from defending the physical self, to defending one’s mind to defending ones expression.  I know you, like me,  see the oneness  of the universe. And that journey is one we go on ALONE. However the right teachers prepare you for it.  Discipline the body, teach the mind to discern and invoke courage to follow one’s heart and passions. That in my opinion encapsulates my education under Sastri Sensei.  From there you do have to walk alone.  Martial Arts is the metaphor, if you will, that we used and still do. It’s our love. It’s our language. It’s our expression. But the target is elsewhere… it’s not just in the fighting.”

With that I felt done, complete. I had never quite articulated the training quite like this.

We finished our tea, and he paid. We started walking out to our cars, and figuring out our next play date. He continued, “Your language was interesting. While most talk about learning techniques and esoteric secrets that only they have, you seem to focus on a different plane.”

“Yes. I think good teachers educate you, teach you how to draw from within. They teach you to learn for & from yourself.  And that is what he taught me how to do. He used to always tell us – do not be my vomit.  Find out for yourself, show me your creativity. In the two decades I have been with him, he never tested two students the same way…..  I believe any art in existence today, especially the classical systems we study were once a hypothesis that was tested and adopted. However people made deities out of the founders, and forgot the message. Don’t get me started on that thread.”

We both laughed. “So the training with Sensei was learning how to learn, and becoming who you are.  And martial arts, was how we explored this. I see effective fighting as one of the benefits, not THE benefit of the learning from him. I continue to learn from him to this day, when we speak every week. We may not discuss MA techniques directly every time, but that’s the thread that informs, instructs and binds us together.”

He nodded, and I knew he understood. He continued, “I want to meet him some day and lets swap notes on specific methods of training next time.” I agreed and promised him that next time Sastri Sensei is in the Bay Area, he would.  I had hoped to do justice to the training and methods, though capturing 2 decades of learning over 2 cups of chai is impossible.  

“You know dude, we are both f****d.  Our schools will never be enrolled to the hilt, and most likely we will die unknown in the arts we love.” I wanted to end on a funny, humbling note.  We laughed hard at the irony of the whole situation.

Being a fellow philosopher and poet he said “Have you heard of Liu Yuxi[ix] famous epitaph -  Inscription for a Humble home?”  I know him well enough to know there had to be a point, and this was not a random tangent.

“Nope”

He stood tall, mockingly imitated an opera performer and began his preparation. I knew the poem meant a lot if he was ready to recite this “by heart.”  I stopped everything to pay complete attention to him for I knew there was going to be a deep point here.

Ever so softly, as though he was sharing a big secret he recited:

 

“A mountain is famous not for its height, but for its immortals.

A lake is magical not because of its depth, but because of its dragons.

This house may be humble, but it is fragrant with my virtue.

The steps are covered with green moss; the window screens reflect the verdant grass.

I laugh and chat with learned gentlemen; there are no illiterates among my visitors.

I can play the harp and read the Vajra Sutra[x].

There is no noise of string and wind instruments to disturb my ears,  nor any documents to tire me out.

Zhu Geliang[xi] lived in a thatched hut in Nanyang;

Yang Ziyun dwelt in a tiny shack in western Shu.

Confucius said, "How can that be considered humble?"

 

There was a deep silence for a minute.  We nodded, hugged warmly and said our good byes.  On my drive home the lines played in my mind, and I was going to soak myself in them. Poetry is the language of the mystical, and the more time you spend with it, the more it unravels. Much like the training with my Sensei, the more I go back to the lessons, the more they unravel.

That was the essence of the training with Sensei, sheer poetry.  Poetry that took hold opened the mind and heart.  Good poetry has layers, and layers. As the reader matures, the meaning of the poem transforms.  The lines sound the same, but are felt and experienced very differently. In the Martial Arts, the moves look the same, but feel and change one completely.  Hence I call it the Poetics of  A Martial Education – it is about how physical, mental and emotional education came together and was aimed to produce a higher ideal than just being an effective fighter. The language he used was martial arts, music, physics and ethics coming together to weave the fabric.

I hope to be able to impact those few students who come to my little dojo, in a similar way that my Sensei did in his.  Damo Arigato Sensei!

   



[i] Poetics is distinguished from hermeneutics by its focus not on the meaning of a text, but rather its understanding of how a text's different elements come together and produce certain effects on the subject

 

[ii] Tai sabaki (体捌き?) is a term from Japanese martial arts and which relates to 'whole body movement', or repositioning. It can be translated as body-management. It is a term used widely in kendo, jujutsu, aikido, judo, karate and ninjutsu. Tai sabaki is usually used to avoid an attack, such that the receiver of the attack ends up in an advantageous position and it is often wrongly referred to as evasion. The key distintion here, esp from a KAR perspective is moving from one circle to the next without interrupting the flow of energy

 

[iii] Marriage to Gravity – The principle of  Structural integration of moving body as one, while employing the advantage of gravity in all techniques. This is something that is deeply explored in Rolfing and related somatic disciplines, and certain schools of Kenpo. From a KAR perspective I have found a direct correlation of this is essential for executing good aiki, esp for the minimal use of force and multiple strikes. In essense this is Tai Ichi – Body as one and managing ones’ relationship to gravity

 

[iv] Counter for counter – it’s a drill where one person feeds a technique, and the other does this defense, with the aim of brining the person down. As he ends his technique, the other begins his defense against it. And this goes on and on. We use it specifically against different systems to help our own understanding of the system we train in.

 

[v] Sticky weapons is my variation drill of doing sticky hands with weapons. In essence one body part and/or weapon is always touching the other, to feel and to begin a series of moves once an opening is created or discovered.  To learn about sticky hands go to  http://kiaiyamabushiryu.tripod.com/Newsletter/sticky_hands_theory_and_practice.html

 

[vi] Kuntao or kuntau (Pe̍h-ōe-jī: kûn-thâu, Tagalogkuntaw) is a Hokkien term for the martial arts of the Chinese community of Southeast Asia, especially the Malay Archipelago. It is most commonly practiced in and associated with IndonesiaMalaysia (particularly Borneo), the Philippines and Singapore. Over time, kuntao and silat have influenced each other to the point where the distinction between the two can sometimes be blurred.

 

[vii] Silat (Minangkabausilek) is a collective word for indigenous martial arts from a geo-cultural area of Southeast Asia encompassing most of the Nusantara, the Malay Archipelago and the entirety of the Malay Peninsula. Originally developed in what are now Indonesiapeninsular Malaysia, south Thailand, and Singapore, it is also traditionally practiced in BruneiVietnam and the southern Philippines. There are hundreds of different styles but they tend to focus either on strikes, joint manipulation, throws, bladed weaponry, or some combination thereof

 

[ix] Liu Yuxi (Wade-Giles: Liu Yu-hsi; simplified Chinese: 刘禹; traditional Chinese: 劉禹錫; pinyin: Liú Yǔxī) (772–842) was a Chinese poet, philosopher, and essayist, active during the Tang Dynasty. He was an associate of Bai Juyi and was known for his folk-style poems. Most famously, he is known for his poem Lou Shi Ming 陋室銘, "Inscription of a crude house". It describes living in a simple dwelling, following a life that is rich in character, refined in culture and learning.

 

[x] The Vajra Cutter Sutra (also known as the Diamond Cutter Sutra or Diamond Sutra) is one of most well-known sutras of Mahayana Buddhism. The Vajra Cutter Sutra is a discourse on the Buddhist concept of emptiness or “Wisdom Gone Beyond.”

 

[xi] Zhuge Liang (181–234),[2] courtesy name Kongming, was a chancellor of the state of Shu Han during the Three Kingdoms period. He is recognised as the greatest and most accomplished strategist of his era, and has been compared to another great ancient Chinese strategist, Sun Tzu.

Deep Immersion To Unfold Principles of Art & Life

Deep Immersion To Unfold Principles of Art & Life

This personal essay will explore the following ideas:1.    The difference between a coach, trainer and, a Sensei

2.    The concept of Finite and Infinite Games, and how only a true teacher takes you to the life playing infinite games

3.    The dangers of certain kinds of modeling—Deep Trance Identification and Borrowed Genius process

4.    How our experience of space-time changes based on mode of learning

5.    The real teacher/Sensei throws you back deeply into yourself

6.    Learning from the ultimate teacher—yourself

7.    The real Alchemy—inner transformation

738098_10151179354646487_2096374976_o
738098_10151179354646487_2096374976_o

Walking down the steps from Udai Vilas (the grand palace of the Udaipur Royalty) toward Lake Pichola is a sight few ever get to see, and one you can never forget. At 5:15 am, Venus shone high above me while the other lake Palaces glittered in the light as though made of gold. The chill of the desert winter was forgotten as serenity and peace engulfed me like a warm blanket. I approached the water and waited as the sun’s rays made their first appearance, and the deep blue waters first turned a light saffron and then a milky white. As the light continued to infuse the environment and the birds started to sing, the reflection of the small wooden boat under me was perfect.

The ambiance created the perfect dojo. I found myself practicing both my advanced Kaze Arashi Ryu Tai Sabaki forms and BaguaZhang’s Thunder Palm change. Martial Arts have been my approach to the deepest recesses of my own soul: for me, the way of the warrior is about a deep immersion, a disciplined approach of going into one’s Self and then offering ones gifts/talents in the service of something far greater than oneself. This is what the Samurai ways mean to me—after all, the very word “Samurai” means to serve. Just as light from the sun changes the colors of the waters, so does one’s life and one’s environment when we allow the light from deep within the Self to radiate and infuse all. That morning, in that sacred aloneness, it was as though a bolt of lightning hit me. It was the perfect metaphor of the unraveling of the Self, of a student’s path towards mastership, towards being a light into himself.

For this requires a very disciplined approach, what I call the principle of deep immersion..

This insight transports me back to a few years ago, to the pristine beauty of a Shugyo at Marble Falls in California’s Sequoia National Park where the water crashes down mountains of marble. The water and surrounding marble slabs had been ice cold as we finished training Irimi Nage variations on the edge of the waterfall. Two students were now preparing lunch and asking questions. Our topic was the difference between the arts as a way of life and as a hobby. “We generally get what we put in, and for me, the real battle is the battle for your consciousness. The right to your consciousness has to be won. It can be neither traded for nor handed to you. And to win that battle is an approach to life, not a hobby. Be it the Warrior Monks of Asia, the Sufis of the Middle East, the Tantriks or the Yogis of India, The Gnostics of Europe, or the Mystics of the American Freedom movement—the discipline is lifelong, and, quite frankly, there are no shortcuts. The price of that freedom, of that consciousness, is your total dedication to it.

After a healthy lunch of fruits, nuts, and some bread, we started the hard hike back to the car. The senior student asked, “does not all martial arts practice lead you to this consciousness, Sensei?” This was a tricky question, for I wanted to do justice—not only to my approach, but to any other as well.

I replied, “there are many paths to this—mine happens to be martial arts. But other paths are just as valid. Over the years, I have learned from many fine teachers, but only a few have left their deep imprints. Those are the ones that truly taught me. In my opinion, you can learn from a coach, a trainer, an awakener, and finally from the Self. Each leads you to a different depth, a different rhythm, and a different perception of space/time and life itself. Each one serves a valuable role, depending on where you want to go. Therefore, choose carefully.”

192204_10150141119526487_2832650_o (1)
192204_10150141119526487_2832650_o (1)

The path through the marbled mountain, sage trees, and ice-cold running water challenged and fascinated us, and our conversations gained an even deeper intensity. Perhaps the new student was both overjoyed and confused with this first wilderness trip, including the training on a waterfall’s edge—for he later confessed these were rather deeper and different conversations than he was used to. “I am not sure I follow, Sensei. Aren’t a coach, trainer, and sensei the same? Are they not just Western titles for the term ‘sensei’?”

“NO! There is a profound difference. Let me share some stories that may perhaps shed some light on this.” I continued, “There was a time when I studied competitive fighting seriously and won many competitions. My instructor emphasized competitive sport fighting techniques, and even though we studied Shotokan, we mostly drilled in just the few techniques that scored points. Combinations like uraken-gyaku zuki-mawashigeri (backfist, reverse punch, and roundhouse kick) were done hundreds of times. When we practiced Kata, we focused on the appearance and scoring ability of the form – not bunkai (applications). The emphasis was on the appearance of perfection. He had a clear goal: win as many medals as possible, and defeat those who stand in our way. But even the best of students has a small window of opportunity for fame, and after that, most just experience emptiness and quit. For he was a coach: he optimized students for the small term, competitive victories and then moved on to the next bunch of competitors.”

The students nodded and asked me to continue. “Z, you have taken a lot of sales excellence courses. You’ve had sales coaches—they come in and teach a few skills that have worked in the past with the goal of winning the account, usually by defeating the competition in any way possible. They probably put a lot of emphasis on things like creating rapport, influence strategies, and language patterns from Neuro Linguistic Programming. Their emphasis is on sizzle and pizzaz to impress, to close and to move on. There are metaphors like “it’s a dog-eat-dog world” or “it’s a rat race.” You live in a Zero-Sum World where the other has to lose in order for you to win. This is what James Carse, in his brilliant book Finite and Infinite Games, has called a Finite Game. Finite Games have a definite beginning and ending. They are played only with the goal of winning. A finite game is resolved within the context of its rules with the winner of the contest being declared and receiving a victory. Rules exist to ensure the game is finite. Think about this for a moment: if you buy into the dog’s world or the rat race metaphor—and even if you win—you still are a dog or a rat. Now, don’t get me wrong. I am not condemning the coach. I am, however, questioning the universe you want to live in and the metaphors you want to live by.”

The late afternoon sun was beating down on us and we sat for a small break. I pulled out my bottle of coconut water, relishing every drop of it. It has a high degree of electrolytes and is very similar to blood plasma in its composition. For me, this is perfect hydration. The two students cut up some mangoes and we devoured the sweet fruit in the hot sun. After burying the bio waste and adhering to our dojo’s “leave no trace behind in the wilderness” policy, we continued our journey down the switchbacks. The students were ready to continue our conversations and the senior student asked, “Sensei – what about the difference between the trainer and sensei?”

“You remember the Kenpo teacher who I have spoken about many times? He put a lot of emphasis on physical fitness along with a few key techniques, especially Kenpo’s signature move—the lightning-fast hand strikes. The physical form and the aesthetics of a powerful body were of prime importance, and we placed a lot of attention on attribute training: speed, power, endurance and flexibility. They are important, but are still in the realm of Finite Games. For while you train the body and its muscles, with age they decline. My instructor, though powerful, had seen his skill decline and seldom demonstrated techniques in full speed or form. Many times he would speak about philosophy and Zen, but it was not a lived or embodied experience. I see him as a trainer, as he trained us to be lean, mean fighting machines. And I must emphasize it was about us being lean fighting machines—not human beings.”

Here, I was marking out and adumbrating my students’ learning patterns with my peripheral vision, as I usually do with my more serious students. The skills I’ve learned over the years of deep immersion in NLP are useful tools in helping teach more effectively. Noticing that the newer student was a little confused and lacking in the martial art context, I attempted to connected things for him: “When you were being coached in sales, you later moved to learn more about personal development, yeah?” He nodded, so I moved in deeper. “You then attended expensive weekend seminars to learn things like strategies for success and modeling excellence—the heart of NLP. You can learn the mathematical precision on how things work, how both your mind and that of the other might work. This is the progression from being coached in applications like rapport and influence blindly, to being trained in learning how things work rapidly. And then there is another way, using processes like Deep Trance Identification (DTI) and Borrowed Genius.”

The students stopped in their tracks, for now I had their complete attention. Learning was about to truly begin. “Deep trance? Borrowing genius? What are you talking about, Sensei?” We sat down under a large tree, unloaded the 40-pound bags, and rehydrated ourselves—which is very important in any backcountry trip. “Milton Ericson coined the term ‘Deep Trance Identification.’ It is a profound state of deep trance where you step into the target/other to experience and identify their world fully from within them. I did DTI multiple times over the years to enter into the world of one of the most iconoclastic trainers in the world.  I stayed in the process for extended periods of time. And it started to change me from the inside. Interestingly, it also started to change my physical body, my tone, my language, my experience of time…everything.” The students got excited and wanted to learn the process from me. This was not the first time this request was made.

In response, like those many times before, I emphatically continued, “Don’t rush, wait a little and let me complete my story. The processes impacted my personal relationships drastically, and as far as my opinion is concerned, I learned a LOT, and my skill level in NLP skyrocketed…but I lost a lot more in the process.

I lost me.

I stopped doing the DTI and Borrowed Genius process completely, and instead invested in unlearning and rediscovering my core essence. Now, I won’t do or teach this process anymore—for I think it takes you away from the journey into yourself. If you want to satisfy your curiosity about this seemingly magical process, look for Milton H Erickon’s work on it, or Win Wegner’s work on Borrowed Genius, or Ostrander’s SuperLearning. And I must warn you again: I do NOT recommend even experimenting with it until you have a firm base in yourself, into the very core of who you are.”

The senior student protested, “Sensei, if I can do DTI with you, I could learn what you have to teach so much sooner and more effectively. Would that not be a logical way to pass down the knowledge you want to hand down?” I recognized the logic—for I had used it to justify my own decision to DTI many years ago—and it had cost me a lot. With compassion and love I said, “What I want to pass down is knowledge far greater than just martial skill. It’s about knowledge of oneself. Now if you spend time to become me effectively, to get access to my skill, metaphors and worldview—who will be you? And what happens if you suddenly discover you don’t like me or my universe—how will you unlearn this? Believe me, I would do you the greatest disservice if I tried to make you an image of me by teaching you these processes and enabling you. I again go back to JC (Joseph Campbell), who once said that the job of the educator is help the students see the vitality in themselves. It is about discovering your own aliveness, your own rhythm, your own beat—not replicating your teacher’s beat or rhythm. Helping you discover your own vitality is the job of an Awakener or True teacher, where as a trainer would be flattered to make you in his image and teach you the skill (for a handsome fee of course.)”

It was time to move on, and as we stood up I showed the students how to triangulate our position and our base camp by using high points in the environment. The path was clear and we resumed our hike. “Sensei, can we continue our conversation? This is fascinating.” The new student was raw, curious, and respectful, and I saw his potential in becoming a long-time apprentice of the arts. So I continued, “As you immerse yourself in truly learning things, you become an apprentice to power— personal power. This is where a true Sensei, true Guru, or true Master comes in. A master (Sheik in Sufism, Guru in Tantra, Sensei in martial arts) is one who forms a formal allegiance with the novice and takes him down the path he has travelled himself in order to help the student find his own path. When you are in his or her presence you will feel pulled into him/her. There is charisma in the truest sense of the word. See, a Sensei means someone who is father-like, someone who has walked the path before you. And the often misused Indian word ‘Guru’ is pregnant with meaning. It means to be heavy with heaven, to be the destroyer of darkness.”

The students and I continued walking slowly down the never-ending switchbacks. “The Sensei, Guru, and Sheikh, are what Robert Frost referred to as awakeners. He introduces you to yourself using everything he has at his disposal. He may use martial arts, dancing, or any other crazy tasks he dreams up to destroy the darkness around you. In the process of destroying this darkness, he expands the light in and around you so more of the universe becomes visible and navigable. Acharya Rajneesh/Osho in one of his discourses referred to this power of the Guru as a voice of God. He is a mirror. He reflects you, reflects God. The Guru always throws you back to yourself and does not bind you to him, because a Guru is life itself. The real Guru is God himself.”

The newer student jumped in with his question: “Who teaches this? Is there a person I can go learn this from? Are there courses to go to?” I laughed hard and said, “Well, you have to find them—and it’s not an easy task. I was lucky to have a few of them in my life, especially Sastri Sensei and Gundappa Uncle. One walked the way of the warrior and the other literally walked with Mahatma Gandhi on the path of non-violence. They both have taught me for two decades in very different ways, but they always pushed me back into/towards myself. Both taught me not to be a copy of them, or as Sensei would say, ‘don’t be my vomit!’ He has a flair for getting his points across dramatically and in a way that sticks. Gundappa Uncle would always gently laugh while advising to listen to that small voice in your own heart and to remember there is no enemy; there is just a part of us that is perhaps unaware. Now that’s what a Sensei or a true Guru really does. They introduce you to yourself, and start you on the journey deep into yourself. That’s why I like the term ‘Awakeners.’”


“They are the ones who bring James Carse’s Infinite Games exquisitely and effectively to life. Infinite games do not have beginnings or ends, and are played with goals of continuous play and bringing more people into their folds. The rules are allowed to change in order to allow the game to go on. Carse has rightfully identified life as the only true example of an infinite game. Hence the Awakeners bring you to life, or to your true vitality—to your aliveness.”

We were quickly approaching both night and end of our supplies, and had perhaps a mile to go. I wanted to wrap up this dialogue before we reached the car, as it required our utmost attention. “You know in India & Tibet we have a saying,” I continued to recite the Sanskrit verses and its translation:

Gurur-Brahma Gurur-Vishnu Gurur-Devo Maheshwarah.
Guru-sakshat Para-Brahma tasmai Shri Gurave Namah.

Guru himself is the creator, sustainer and the destroyer. He is the very transcendental divinity, (the timeless life-principle, which is the very essence of the creator) My reverential salutations to that glorious teacher.

“A guide in the ancient stone temples of Halebidu recently joked with me that that the word GOD is an acronym for Generator (Brahma), Operator (Vishnu) and Destroyer (Shiva). And damn, was he right on. The Guru is referred to as God in many Asian cultures because he helps create your soul, sustains your development, and systematically destroys your false ego. Replace the word ‘Guru’ with ‘Sheik’ or ‘Sensei,’ and you still have the same results. Don’t be stuck on the title.  And don’t assume I am suggesting you treat him like one; however, when I do find such a teacher, I treat him as the greatest blessing.”

The senior student was quick to catch on and said, “So this is why you always quote to us Hesse’s lines of ‘Every man is a journey to himself’.” I was overjoyed and said, “YES. Yes. Yes. The greatest secret perhaps is to find yourself where life happens naturally, effortlessly, and rightfully. Where the aliveness infuses you, and infuses all that comes around you. When you reach this place, nothing is now desired, yet everything is given. Allama Iqbal, one of Pakistan’s eminent poets captures this beautifully in Urdu:

Khudi ko kar buland itna ke har taqder se pehle
Khuda bande se ye poche bata teri raza kia hai

Make thy Self’s (higher self) presence/will so strong , that before every destiny is carved – the master asks his servant what is thy wish

We reached the car—the eight miles of hiking back after training on the waterfalls had come to an end. I wanted to close this loop before we headed back home: “Next, after been thrown deeply into yourself over and over again by your teacher, you start to wake up to yourself. You start becoming an individual, and in many ways a mirror back to the world. Perhaps now you too can help shine that light into and through someone else. I believe that’s all there is. In listening to Bucky Fuller many times, I was attracted to an idea where he referred to himself as ‘Guinea Pig B’ and experimented with the universal laws on himself. This is what Krishnamurti calls the pathless path you have to thread. You are the experiment of nature. You are the goal. You are the process. You are consciousness that needs to be awakened from the hypnosis society puts you in. You are IT. This is a continuous process. When learning more and more of yourself—from yourself—stops, you stop.”

291138_10151102374171034_1107527848_o (1)
291138_10151102374171034_1107527848_o (1)

“And the more you journey into yourself, the lighter you become to yourself and the world around you. That’s what the dojo is supposed to do. To me, the word ‘dojo’ signifies the place of the way to yourself, and the sensei is the one who helps you find yourself. And for this journey, you need to have a deep immersion into the art that calls you. Surrender to it, and in the process you will surrender into yourself. The art you learn is also then transformed by the new life your Being will breathe into it. Once it again rejuvenates, it becomes fresh and timeless. What’s required is a deep immersion for the principles of nature itself to unravel.”

With this, we got into the car and started our drive back to the Bay Area. I had hoped I had explained to my students the difference between a coach, trainer, and a sensei. We had been driving mostly in silence for over 90 minutes when the senior student asked me, “Sensei you mentioned space-time in passing, and how that’s different in each approach. I am not sure I follow it. Can you say more?” This could go on all night, I thought, and I wanted to keep the contexts clean. So I said, “Think about it this way—a coach, a trainer, and an Awakener will take you to different depths. Each one of these approaches/worlds has a different rhythm, a different orientation of time and space. Let me use the example of cross-cultural communication, or anthropology, to be more precise. Ed Hall did some pioneering work here, and if you find time and want to be enriched, study his books—try The Silent Language, The Hidden Dimension, Beyond Culture and The Dance of Life. Now, back to cross-cultural communication. If you study a foreign culture from a book, or take a short course on it, you will not even scratch the surface. You are trying to cheat your way through a culture. Perhaps a little training in the language and its culture will open a bigger world for you. It will fascinate, but the differences will still frustrate you. Z (the senior student)—you have experienced this coming from Mexico to the United States a few years ago. Only a deep immersion into the culture will unravel its secrets to you over time, until it no longer is foreign. So each one of these ways of learning will open the world to you on different levels, and your experience of both the space you can feel and the time you can experience will transform completely. Similarly, as you dwell deeper, so will your sense of your Self, your world, and your time/timelessness.”

We reached home, and I was glad to be in bed. That next Tuesday’s session in the dojo, I began with a verse from the Rig Veda I had learned from Maharishi Mahesh Yogi:

Richo akshare parame vyoman Yasmin deva adhivishve nisheduh Yastanna veda kimricha karishyati Ya ittadvidus ta ime samasate

The verses of the Veda exist in the collapse of fullness (the kshara of ‘A’) in the field in which reside all the Devas, the impulses of Creative Intelligence, the laws of nature responsible for the whole manifest universe. He whose awareness is not open to this field, what can the verses accomplish for him? Those who know this level of reality are established in evenness, wholeness of life.

177040_10151094629171487_355574619_o
177040_10151094629171487_355574619_o

“You see, until you don’t realize the source of your creativity and unfolding that lies deep within yourself, and until you don’t tap into this resource, you are just incomplete. All learnings—whether from journals or books or seminars—will be incomplete and not a state of reality. This is another way of thinking about the immersion principle, and the immersion is into oneself. Only the immersion deeply into oneself can be the wellspring of life. The Self is ultimately the MahaGuru (the great teacher),  the greatest Sensei. This is the journey from fragmentation to wholeness, and sometimes it is trial by fire to get there, but every bit is worth it. The tools I know are here in the martial arts primarily—so let’s get on with our training.” And with that, we started our practice on the variations of Irimi Nage, much like we had done on the edge of the waterfall.

But, at the end of the class, I wanted to connect the space/time differences back to the martial arts. “A coach will teach you to score points by focusing on your opponent’s miai (distance) and timing your attacks to his movement. A trainer starts to bring your awareness of your circle of safety (space/distance), and how to throw off the opponent’s timing by changing yours, perhaps using concepts like broken rhythm and variations of your own speed. The Awakener takes you to a place where a dance is happening, where flow is induced and nothing is interrupted. And when deep in yourself, you just enjoy the play of space/time around when need be. Enough for today. Go discover it yourself.”

I find myself now sharing this path of learning and self-expression fully with all the students who come along. My personal goal is to be a true Sensei—like my teachers before me. The path is fulfilling, and in the course of teaching the whole immersion method, I find that both my students and I change deeply. The better description is that it’s mutual alchemy. I was asked once why I don’t teach more students or in studios, and this is precisely the reason I won’t. This method of teaching and learning can only happen in small groups—the bond is sacred, and the only limits your results have are those of your input. This method of both learning and teaching have left me a far richer man than I was before—for the importance and power of what you deal with here matters far more than money or fame.

And in closing, it’s my hope that as you immerse deeply into yourself with whatever tools/paths take you there, that just as the Lake Pichola at sunrise transforms the colors from the engulfed darkness to the beautiful saffron to the clear white, a life like the boat is mirrored back for you beautifully.

– Mahipal Lunia, 9th January 2013

– Stream of consciousness writing to explain the guiding philosophy of Mt. View Aiki Kai by Mahipal Lunia Sensei. These are his own personal views, and do not represent the art/s, system/s, or teacher/s he has studied with.

Technorati Tags: Deep Immersion,Irimi Nage,Marble Falls,Coach,Trainer,Sensei,James Carse,Finite and Infinite Games,attribute training,Adumberate,Edward T Hall,Deep Trance Identification,Borrowed Genius,Awakener,Sastri Sensei,Gundappa Uncle,Osho,Allama Iqbal,Khudi,Alchemy,Mahipal Lunia,Mahipal Lunia Sensei

Highly Recommeneded Resources

Beauty, Elegance & Grace As Guideposts (GPS for Your Soul)

Beauty, Elegance & Grace As Guideposts (GPS for Your Soul)

This is a piece of stream of consciousness writing on one of the key values/guiding principles of Mt. View Aiki Kai: holding an aesthetic perspective. This personal essay will explore the following ideas:

  1. Beauty is what marks the pollen path/golden path: the path where one finds oneself in the lap of infinity
  2. Fear is the result of chaos/chapel perilous, and the way out is a return to and through beauty (elegance/symmetry)
  3. Beauty heals, transforms, and enchants the world
  4. Beauty emerges from you and your unique creations when your Personal Impulses are followed completely
  5. The God of Beauty, the masks of eternity
  6. Stalking Beauty to find oneself, making Beauty the GPS for your soul

 

What follows in the next 3,000-odd words is my understanding of this elusive perspective, at this point in time.

I have anonymized the names of my students out of respect for their privacy.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The world seemed to have become disenchanted and had transformed into a very scary place. My neighbor’s footsteps on the second floor would make my heart race and I would break out in a cold sweat. I had curled up in the bathroom tub, the bathroom door shut: the fear had found home in my body-soul. My world was shrinking, and even though I was locked away in the bathroom for well over 12 hours on this one Saturday in 2008, I did not feel safe. For over the past few months, I had started to cut myself away from the world, friends, and family. It was at this point—with the help of numerous therapy sessions (to deal with my deep trauma, my personal demons)—that I realized I did not want to live like this—in a world filled with fear, immobile to deal with life. Yet, I still had not found a way out of the paranoia and chaos my life had become.

beauty 4

Time was at a standstill, my heart went into palpitations. The tears rolled down, and even though—after a while—the tears dried, my head still pounded with pain and the body remained frozen there in the tub. I wanted a way out. I did not want the fear to grip me to the point of immobility. My mind and heart screamed for relief, and it was in those periods of intense pain that I started writing once again, especially my Urdu poetry. It was here that I truly understood this shaayari which I had recited countless times, but had never really understood until then:

Dil Ki Kharracho ko log shayaari Kahate hai to dark nahi hota/ It does not bother me When people call the wailings of my heart poetry,

Dard to taab hota hai, jab log wah wah kahate hai/ However it hurts deeply  me when people praise those lines with wows’ and claps

 

During one of these sessions, pouring my heart out in writing, I remembered this was not the first time I had frozen with fear—and in the past I had found my way through it. I wanted to replicate that, and find my way back. I wanted to model my own way like how NLP had exquisitely taught me to do:

Modeling is the art and science of replicating excellence. It’s built on the premise that success leaves clues, and to replicate any success in a human endeavor, you have to replicate what the model does exquisitely well. From my perspective it is very mathematically precise and creates astounding results. However, in layman’s terms, you want to be able to track and replicate the physiology (the way the body is held, thus directly impacting what part of brain is used), the belief systems (which dictate what is true and what is possible), the language the model uses (in communicating with the Self and with the other) and, I would add, one’s personal teleology (directionality of his being). When these are tracked and modeled, they can then be “installed” in others—much like loading a computer program. The Radical Change Group will shortly be producing a series on this, if the field of modeling is of interest to you. I would also heartily recommend the works of Robert Dilts, especially the Strategies of Genius. Now, back to the story.

My mind raced back to my time as a young teenager studying Shotokan Karate. One evening, my sport karate coach pitted me against the current National Champion for Kumite (sparring) practice. The champ’s reputation for a fantastic mawashi geri (roundhouse kick) preceded him and stuck fear in the hearts of most of his opponents. As I sparred with him, he continued to easily plaster me over and over again, while I stood there, frozen with fear, like his own personal makiwara (wooden dummy used for striking practice in martial arts). To add insult to injury, he would tell me how he was going to score the next point, and then proceeded to do so. The fear of facing him made those Thursday evening sparring sessions dreadful encounters, and I especially hated the smile on his face every time his roundhouse kick connected to rearrange my face.

This went on for at least a few months. But then, one fateful Thursday evening, things shifted. I sat, watching him spar, and saw the beauty and efficiency of his technique. I was overjoyed by the possibilities of the human body. I was now sitting there, enjoying the elegance of his mastery. The fear and dread vanished, and was replaced with a fascination calling me forth to participate. Now, I could not wait to get into the ring with him and, as I did, something miraculous happened: I started to flow with him as though in a dance. I evaded his famed roundhouse kicks and, for the first time, connected my roundhouse kick to his face. Not once, but thrice in that one evening. I could not believe it, and I was ecstatic. My coach was shocked, and so was the champion. From then on, my sparring would change completely—I continued to win against other national champions over the years, and the roundhouse kick that had caused me so much anguish became my weapon of choice. This was the beginning of my being known for my mawashigeri (roundhouse kick, as seen in the picture above)

No one around me had realized what had happened, yet something in the very core of me had shifted that evening, and a complete metamorphosis transpired. And this pattern repeated itself many times across different contexts. For example, high altitudes used to scare me due to my asthma. But my dad encouraged me to go high into the Himalayas, and to just face it and open myself up to whole new worlds. So, in the summer of my 15th or 16th birthday, I headed into the Himalayas to climb Sar Pass, often referred to as “the gateway to heaven.” It was a 15-day adventure, and I had never done anything like it before. I was quite scared. Walking through the forests sent shivers down my spine, and in some places I froze with fear—especially when the night would settle in. I could not even see my own hand in this darkness, and the sounds of the forest animals magnified my fear by many folds. But one night, I noticed something—a startling discovery. Because I had lost touch with my body, my mind would race and create the worst-case scenarios. The release would only come in the morning when, overjoyed with beauty, I merged with the environment. There was nowhere to go and nothing to do but just bask in the radiance of everything. What released the fear—and also the psychosomatic triggers of my asthma—was beauty, and losing myself in it.

Frank Herbert’s epic novel Dune holds a great scene where Lady Jessica teaches her son Paul Atreidies the litany against fear. The book captures in great detail the dread and its ability to freeze people, especially during the kind of tests Paul has to take from Mohaim. (This freezing is what causes deep trauma. If you wish to study the structure of Trauma and ways around it, I highly recommend Waking The Tiger By Peter Levine and also listening to these recordings gifted to the world with the Radical Change Group project). Lady Jessica instructs Paul to memorize and feel the litany with his totality. He experiences its magic during the test of pain and many times later. Reciting it aloud, you cannot help but be pulled into it and feel its wisdom. Try it.

I must not fear.
Fear is the mind-killer.
Fear is the little-death that brings total obliteration.
I will face my fear.
I will permit it to pass over me and through me.
And when it has gone past I will turn the inner eye to see its path.
Where the fear has gone there will be nothing.
Only I will remain.

What my experience in the Himalayas taught me was that arriving at the purity of the “I” is critical to dealing with fear.  The lack of control over chaos (which accelerates paranoia) is what causes fear and in its worst case, leads you into deep trauma.  I know this very well from first hand experiences that lasted over a span of few years. I remember the many times this fear caused me to lock myself in rooms and cut myself away from friends, family and the world. For this was my own “Chapel Perilous.”

I was introduced to the idea of Chapel Perilous while reading Timothy Leary’s Game of Life, but it started to make more sense in my interactions with Robert Anton Wilson (read his Cosmic Trigger 2) and Antero Alli (read AngelTech or engage in his 8 Circuit Mind Course.)  Uncle Bob once explained it as “Chapel Perilous”—that vortex where cosmological speculations, coincidences, and paranoia seem to multiply and then collapse, compelling belief or lunacy, wisdom or agnosticism.”

Back in the tub, I knew what I had to do. It was not easy by any stretch of imagination to make that journey from the mind—where the paranoia exists—to the body/heart—where the joy resides. The fear grips you, and you have to let it pass through you. It took me a while, but I stood up, walked to the door, slowly unlocked it, and opened it a crack. I slipped out to the dojo after a few weeks absence. Those were the longest 400 meters I have walked in my life: from my apartment to the park. My students were happy to see me, and I remember Fernando asking me “How are you, Sensei? It’s good to have you back.” He then stepped away to let me lead the class again. And in working out and being with my students, I remembered the magic of the art of Kaze, and the joy it has always given me. The beauty, elegance, and sheer effectiveness of the art had always brought me home to myself. For this art serves as my guidepost to what the Navajo Indians have called the Pollen Path.

beauty 2

 “Oh, beauty before me, beauty behind me, beauty to the right of me, beauty to the left of me, beauty above me, beauty below me, I’m on the pollen path.” Pollen is the life source. The Pollen Path is the path towards one’s center, towards one’s heart. It finally clicked for me that beauty was the marker of the path, and fear was really the absence of beauty, or the absence of the life source itself.

I was once again in somewhat of a state of ecstasy. Over the next few months, I had more episodes of the fear paralyzing me, but now I used beauty as the guidepost to return to my center and towards my deepest sense of embodiment. This embodiment started leading me out of the Chapel Perilous without losing my sanity completely. Beauty and radiance as a state of being now marked the way. I started to understand what Osho had said repeatedly: “Look deep into your heart. Listen to the still small voice within. And remember one thing: life is fulfilled only through longings, never through ambitions. Life becomes blissful only through the heart, never through the mind. Mind creates science, the heart creates religion. The mind can give you better technology, better gadgets. The heart gives you the real, ultimate values: love, bliss, truth, freedom, awareness, God. And a life without these values is valueless.”

In short, my understanding of Chapel Perilous is a place where your soul goes when lost, and it is usually an “out of body experience.” The way out is the return from the mind back to a sense of deep embodiment. This deep embodiment is also “the rapture of being alive” and perhaps the true secret as explained in Hakuin’s Song of Meditation where he ends the poem with “this very body, the Buddha.”

I had made a big decision: to stay true to my martial arts path. Now and again, I would make beauty the true marker and true perspective in my life, and explore the most beautiful places in Nature I could find. I had not done any unmapped backcountry explorations in over ten years, and I yearned for the sense of freedom and expansion I had experienced while crossing through Sar Pass and exploring Ladhak among dozen other ten-plus day explorations during my teen years.

The following  weekend I jumped into my Audi and took off, alone. After a 4 1/2 hour drive I found myself in the  Yosemite National Park’s Visitor Center, collected maps, bought a John Muir book and headed off to explore some trails along the Tioga Pass with my 40-pound backpack. I headed onto the quietest of trails that the tall, blonde Park Ranger had suggested and boy, was he right. Hours of walking absolutely alone and bathing in the beauty was therapeutic. Late afternoon I found a fantastic camping spot with 360 degree views and quickly unpacked the tent. I brewed some green tea and sat down reading the Muir notebooks. This amazing explorer’s perspective spoke deeply to my heart and just by looking all around me I could see why he was so deeply in love with the Sierras. One particular reflection moved me to tears: “When we contemplate the whole globe as one great dewdrop, striped and dotted with continents and islands, flying through space with other stars all singing and shining together as one, the whole universe appears as an infinite storm of beauty. Everybody needs beauty as well as bread, places to play in and pray in, where nature may heal and give strength to body and soul alike.”

After the soul-nourishing weekend, I was back in the dojo the following Tuesday evening. We worked on the basics and I showed them the exquisite elegance of cross blocks in dealing with oncoming attacks. “You know, the thing that sold me on Kaze Arashi Ryu (KAR) was watching Sastri Sensei doing the cross blocks, and in it I saw an answer to a question on body positioning (Tai Sabaki) that I had not resolved even after years of practicing Shotokan Karate, Okinawan Kenpo, and Wushu.  The simplicity and effectiveness of Sastri Sensei executing cross blocks had been enough for me to know this I had to learn this art, embody it, and make it my own. You see, back then I did not know it was the sense of symmetry, elegance, and beauty that had captivated me. It was the gracefulness of Sensei’s movements that had had me entrained completely as though in a trance, in Aesthetic Arrest.”

One of my students asked, “Arrest what?” I smiled, and reminded myself to speak in the language that the others can translate, for the inability of student in understanding something is the failure of the teacher, not the student. I stepped back a bit, took a deep breath, and quieted my mind. I looked at the five students who had gathered around in a circle, waiting to understand, as the night began to creep in. This scene reminded me of the many nights we had stayed back after class while apprenticing under Sastri Sensei: we would hang on to his every word, as though the unraveling of new worlds was happening right before our eyes. Now, it was my turn to pass this forward.

“I have long told you boys to study Joseph Campbell. Campbell similarly studied a literary giant named James Joyce. It was Joyce who first coined the term ‘Aesthetic Arrest’ in his book Portrait of The Artist. The way I understand it, it is the experience of radiance as you behold an object. This radiance is the hidden power behind the world shining through in a physical form. You are arrested or mesmerized in silence by the wholeness, the harmony, and the rapture. You experience an enchantment of the heart. This enchantment is what will bring you from your mind to your heart. This will get you out of the Chapel Perilous that is created by the mind, and bring you to joy that resides in the heart. I am just rediscovering this. And as you rediscover this, you will find that you offer yourself in service to the world and you cherish it all…and perhaps even understand the quote ‘We have met the enemy, and it is us.’”

 

The class was supposed to be done by seven, and it was way past eight. One of my senior students jumped in, “Sensei, I have a few questions. May we speak about it as we get a bite to eat?” We piled into our cars and rushed to our regular place—a nearby, quaint Chinese Vegetarian restaurant off El Camino Real—and ordered our favorite Singapore noodles, sautéed mushrooms, and fried tofu dishes. Our conversation continued: “Sensei, I have been thinking that I have experienced that arrest you speak about when I listen to Latin Music. Where else can I experience this?”

“It’s good there is something that gives you that wholeness and you experience that beauty that brings the world to a stop. Another way is to experience nature. Perhaps a trip into the backcountry, cut away from everything in civilization.” We cleaned up the plates, sipped some Jasmine tea and, I noticed the emergence of a hunch—an impulse from deep within. I was not sure where this would lead me, yet I knew I had to stay true to it. As we walked back to our cars, I laid out a proposal to the students. “Let’s organize a Shugyo deep into the backcountry of California. We will go away for the weekend and train in the wilderness. Let’s head to Sequoia Redwood Forests—I know this old abandoned trail where the redwoods rise to kiss the heavens. There will be very few people, if any. Let us find that beauty and train in it.”

The students were as excited as I was, and the three of them cancelled their other plans to make the trip three days later. Thus began the marriage of martial arts with backcountry exploration and the training in nature’s own lap. We track our progress by stalking beauty—much like a hunter tracks prey—and allow that beauty to transform us. My love of photography had returned, for I now also worked on creatively capturing that sense of harmony that few of us learn to see. But I know that this beauty was the same marker of Novajo’s Pollen Path and Frank Herbert’s Golden Path (the path leading humanity to infinity).

The results of this marriage were nothing short of stunning. I transformed, and so did my core group of students. Personally, my photography has improved dramatically—for it is the exotic marriage of martial arts, adventure trips, and an aesthetic perspective created by the rather unique expression of the martial arts I have studied for over twenty years. My periods of being frozen by fear have diminished greatly to the point where they are almost non-existent. My relationships with friends, family, and nature have improved.  And my students have opened up to beauty in their lives as well: a few of them have taken up serious hiking, while others returned to dancing. One particular student who was a serious climber in the past, but had not climbed in over seven years, returned to his love of nature and, in his words, “a return to peace.” He transformed so much that he took leave from his high profile job for a month to explore Denali National Park and scale Mt McKinley, fulfilling one of his long cherished dreams. He returned looking ten years younger.

These trips and training have continued over the years, and none of the students have wanted to miss them. On one recent trip to Shasta Trinity National Forest in November of 2012, as I was clicking the picture of old trees, a student asked, “How is that I take the same photograph as you, Sensei, but it does not come out even remotely as beautiful?” I laughed hard, along with the two other students, and I replied, “A teacher’s job is to teach you how to look; however, it’s entirely up to you as to what you see and where you find harmony. Keep at it, and more importantly, do it your way. As you find more and more of yourself, I believe it will show in the pictures or other art you truly create, because you will capture those same trees in your own way. You will capture the trees while being in empathy with them, almost as though they will direct you to that place of perfect harmony. Trust me, this will happen—but you have to keep at it, and ask the tree permission to know it, and, as in the poem Lost, it will respond. You have to learn to listen. This is the same with our martial arts practice of Kaze Arashi Ryu. You have to pay close attention, let its beauty teach you, and then make it uniquely yours. Ultimately, you must transcend it, too.”

By now we had reached the top of Mt. Eddy after a hard, hard climb. We had three injured climbers, but the will and the promise of beauty had bought us to the very top. And then, the views of Shasta to the east, Shasta Lake to the south, the Pinnacles to the west, and Klamath Lakes to the north rejuvenated us completely. All of our tiredness was gone, the pain from our sore muscles and injuries was forgotten: ecstasy rolled in, and we cherished that sight through the night into the morning while on the top of that mountain, all by ourselves. Once again, Beauty had come to the rescue, and the reward was great.

Beauty

In the early morning, after packing up in the below-freezing temperature, we got ready to head back down to train on the tanto and Kokyo Ho by the emerald-colored Dead Man’s Lakes. As we carefully started to slide down the loose gravel and big rocks at an almost 70 degree angle, I remembered JC’s brilliant insight: “In choosing your god, you choose your way of looking at the universe. There are plenty of gods, choose yours. The god you worship is the god you deserve.” And I said out loud, “I choose this, I choose beauty.” Gods are meant to be role models, masks of eternity and guide-posts to a good life. I choose beauty. My longing was now to find the beauty, elegance, symmetry, and wholeness that the John Muirs, the Joseph Campbells, my Senseis, the Buckminister Fullers, the Ansel Adams, and the Oshos had found before me.

When I relayed this wish to my students later on, one of the more religiously staunch students said to me “Sensei that would be considered sacrilege in many circles.” I did not miss a beat as I said, “Absolutely. This is the beginning of one’s duty of sacred rebellion.” She was taken aback, and I let her sit with it a bit and then recited a Shayari/poem I had written in Urdu not too long ago:

Haar Mazhab Nein Humhe Aab Khafir Karaar Kaar Diya

Iss Liye Uss Ke Darbaar mein Humhe apna karaar kaar diya

Now every religion has  branded me an Infidel Hence in HIS court I have found a seat among his other lovers/heretics

“You are becoming a philosopher in a materialistic world. Careful,” she said, somewhat teasingly. I looked at her and responded, “No, not a philosopher—as what a philosopher does is makes innumerable distinctions, splits things apart. The realm I am speaking about is bringing things together as one. This is the realm of the mystic. Now, I am discovering the mystery, becoming it, and allowing it to just be exactly as it is. You can too!”

With that I close this, and hope you too find yourself on your own pollen path, your golden path by paying attention to its marker—Beauty. For Beauty, I have found, heals, transforms, and enchants your world. This beauty is your guidepost into the lap of infinity. May you be nourished along the pollen/golden path. And may Beauty serve as the GPS to your Soul!

- Mahipal Lunia on the 16th of December, 2012

- Stream of consciousness writing to explain the guiding philosophy of Mt. View Aiki Kai by Mahipal Lunia Sensei. These are his own personal views and do not represent the art/s, system/s, or teacher/s he has studied with.

Embracing Aliveness - Following Your Fascinations Fully

Embracing Aliveness - Following Your Fascinations Fully

“People say that what we're all seeking is a meaning for life. I don't think that's what we're really seeking. I think what we're seeking is an experience of being alive, so that our life experiences on the purely physical plane will have resonance within our own innermost being and reality, so that we actually feel the rapture of being alive. That's what it's all finally about.”   Joseph Campbell on The Power of Myth

 fascination The cold breeze in November at 4 am does more than wake you up, as I ride a few kilometers to pick a friend up for our early morning Kenpo classes. This was a daily routine, been going on for over two years to train with a rather eccentric and rather combat oriented  Sensei (teacher). I would return home at about 7:30 am to my frenzied mom who would make sure I am not late to school, and was our daily ritual for her to ask me “what teenage boy goes to bed at 9 so he can wake up to train at 4 am? what is this madness, what is this fascination with the martial arts, its not going to be profession you know- you are going to either become a doctor or work on growing the family business.” I would hurriedly gobble my breakfast down with a glass of milk and rush to school, and then to repeat the same process day in and out.  Fast forward a few years and the same cycle goes on with my training in Aiki under Sastri Sensei, and I remember that Christmas day clearly in 1996 when Ma’am ( as we referred to Sensei’s wife Terri) just looked at us and told Sastri Sensei “dont you want the boys to go home and celebrate the holiday.” and Sensei said “well they are here to train and I am going to teach them.”

Not many people understand this fascination, not many understand this passion, to many it seems madness and yet this is the path the individual must take in order to find healing, wholeness and give meaning to an otherwise meaningless existence.  However following the impulses that are generated and informed through your body proper is not an easy task, staying true to what emerges and informs you is an even taller order and yet the greatest blessing if you choose to stay true to them. Many disciplines teach you how to get in touch with them, however the hard part is staying true to what emerges. If you wish you explore these mediums I personally would based on my personal study recommend Mythic Body Work, Theatre, 5 Rhythms Dancing and The warrior ways.

These impulses have a way of leading you towards what one needs, they are more or less “postcards from the unconscious” waiting to become/made conscious through ones awareness of the body proper. They also open up new realms and worlds and create what Martin Heidegger once called “throwness.”  Let me share another small story here to show how this works. The training with Sastri Sensei continued 6 days a week for 3 years non stop, Sastri Sensei had left his comfortable life in New York City and come to Bangalore, and my path crossed his as I was getting ready to head out to Australia. I cancelled my plans of Australia and stayed to study with Sensei who had repeatedly said a few times to us “I am giving you three years of my life, the rest you have to do.” A small group (3 of us, of which I am the only one teaching today) worked with him almost 6 days a week while most others showed up 2-4 times a week. After that Sensei returned to the USA, and as life would have it, I found myself in school right in the same town, about 5 miles from Sensei and my training with him continued, and was introduced to Henri Robert Vilaire Shihan – with whom I have studied since 1998. During this time in the early 1990’s Sastri Sensei also introduced the small group to a whole body of knowledge including the works of Napoleon Hill, Anthony Robbins, Earl Nightingale among others.

While going through the Unlimited Power seminar tapes on Sensei’s and Ma’am’s recommendation, I got fascinated with a new subject – Neuro Linguistic Programming. The magic of rapport, the power of modeling, the structure of the subjective experience, the chaos of grammar & the grammar of chaos soon opened whole new worlds.  What followed was a furious learning and seminar attendance around the world to learn about the human mind, the power of discipline, the structure of subjective experience and the ability to learn rapidly. My teachers ranged from world renown trainers to absolutely secluded teachers who had shunned public limelight. This path continued to marvel and fascinate me. In 2003-2004 along with Sergey Berezin we started the Stanford NLP Club at Stanford University, Palo Alto, CA. At the Stanford NLP club I met with Arman Darini. This was the beginning of a beautiful friendship and great collaboration. Around 2006 the three of us got together again on University Avenue over a cup of coffee. I was working for a large software company, Sergey was designing systems and Arman was laying the foundation of his training business. Over coffee based on an impulse I threw out an idea of the three of us collaborating to bring about a new kind of service to the world – 3 perspectives on some of the topics of transformation, with NLP being the common language which we needed, as I was a Strategist (economics, business and martial arts as majors), Sergey was a scientist (Physics and systems science) and Arman was an entrepreneur (Artificial intelligence and Math major) .

Following this impulse we started the Radical Change Group (RCG)with a simple idea of transformation as a gift to all, no advertising or marketing, and a deep dive into topics that touch us deeply. This has from the humble beginnings in 2006 has bought us in touch with such path breakers and pioneers as Paul Rebillot, Richard Roberts, Gabriella Roth, Kathy Altman, Paul Kordis, Antero Alli, Marshall Thurber, David Neenan to name a few. This also got us access to the Nobel Laureate Buckminster Fullers lost tapes, Joseph Campbell's private recordings and the Advaitha vedanta of Arnauld Desjardin.  RCG aslo then worked with Sastri Sensei and Henri Robert Vilaire to bring about the first recordings of the obscure art i practiced and teach Kaze Arashi Ryu to the world in their own words for the first and only time. The results to the date are nothing short of stunning for me – over 210 published recordings, over 1 million downloads from 100 plus countries. That one impulse to study NLP and following it opened a whole new world of learning, that one impulse followed honestly of starting NLP created deep lasting friendships and some unprecedented contributions. This IMHO is the power of following ones impulses honestly, especially when the world does not understand it, and will want you to “get real” or “follow the path/system”

Fast forward a few years, on a Shugyo in the Sequoia Mountains where the redwood trees kiss the heavens, a student asked me “Sensei I am fascinated by so many things, if i followed them all I wont have time to do anything, how do i know which one is the most productive?” I laughed as i remembered having the same question many years ago and no one seemed to be able to help me with it then. I looked at him with both a mischief and some compassion in my eyes and asked “ what brings you ALIVE?” he looked at me more puzzled than ever, and I let him sit with the confusion and silence, which he started to fill with a 100 different things except answering what bought him alive. After a lil while, as he had exhausted himself of all answers from his mind, and noticing an emptying I continued “ there is a difference between curiosity and fascination – when you are truly fascinated by something, you lose track of time/space and there is a union/fusion that happens. The subject (you), the object and the process of relating/knowing between them  become one. There comes about a certain lightness in the being, and doors that were once closed suddenly open up, as though they were always waiting for you to wake up, to become Alive".

“Alive ?? Am I not alive right now??” he asked. “well aliveness is a quality that when you dial in, the world also comes alive. I think most people in the past have seen this as a rather chance happening, or luck. However I will tell you that this is an analogue dance – meaning you can track what happens in the body proper in a specific syntax and if you follow the strategy you will find the same result. Let me be a little more clear – this aliveness is a State of Consciousness and has a method/strategy to access it. By studying modeling you learn how to replicate a behavior in the other,  however what we want is to model ourselves in this state of aliveness, in this state of absolute flow, in this state of you being your best. Once you model this, you now know you a strategy and syntax to get to that state of aliveness. Bingo you are there, as simple as that.”

This analogue dance is what the Sufis pursue when they dance into ecstacy, this state is what elite sports persons dial into to arrive at their best performance, this state is what the Gnostics/Tantrics/Heretics/Magickians have called the “God Code.” In the past this has remained an accidental state for most, however it need not be. Much like The Swan in Rilke’s great poem, one can condescend to glide majestically. The study of NLP helped me learn how not to just model this, but also amplify this state greatly. All one has to do is follow simple steps

  1. Find the state where everything for you has been possible, where you have been totally alive
  2. Model the syntax of how you arrive there – in simple words what has to happen in the body for you to arrive there
  3. Follow the syntax/sequence with precision
  4. Now run through the sequence over and over again, till you can form a circuit with it
  5. Anchor it, and keep dialing into this state of BEING ALIVE”

“as simple as that eh Sensei? Then why does not everyone do it?” asked the student with a smug on his face. I have been used to this and have long given up trying to convince people. “Well simple does not mean easy, nor does it mean everyone does it. All it means is that its simple, it is  elegant that's it. Now I have my theory on why everyone does not do it but that's not relevant, what's relevant is that most people are not alive, so why do what most do? obviously the answer is elsewhere. Aliveness is an individual phenomena, its a creative act, and every truly creative act is also an act of rebellion – a rebellion against the mass hypnosis that society puts on all its members. This kind of aliveness is considered dangerous as it brings forth the true kind of creative acts – acts that change the structure of what is. I have told you guys many a times that I am only interested in making maps that change the territory. This is that realm. Guys I have told you of this other story, when I was training with Henri Robert Vilaire Sensei  this one time, and he was quite sick. I was doubtful whether we would be able to train, esp. since I had flown over a 1000 miles to study with him. He slowly walked put on his gi and as he got on the mat he transformed. He proceeded to throw me around like a rag doll for the rest of the day. This IMHO or rather in my languaging is him dialing into his Aliveness, and the warrior ways are his way. This is not an accidental phenomena, this is a possible state of consciousness available to all who will learn to pay attention to themselves in a new way. Perhaps this is the true meaning of the old adage  Man, know thyself”

If we do not get to know that which is within us and proceeds to act through us, there remains very little chance for us to know truly know anything else. The mystics have always understood this well, esp. the Sufis’.Their poetry always gives a clue or points the finger to the moon so to say. Lets look at these two examples that say so much about this same quality of following your fascinations and that state of aliveness. The first one is by RumiLet yourself be silently drawn by the strong pull of what you truly love.”  and the second is by the Pakistani Poet Sir Allama Iqbal

Pila dey mujhay woh mey pardah soz Key aati nahee fasl-e-gul roz roz Woh mey jis say roshan zameer-e-hayat Who mey jis say hai masti-e-kainat Pour me the wine which burns the veil For the season of the rose does not come everyday That wine which reveals the essence of life That wine which intoxicates the universe

 

This Maasti-e-Kainat is what we are after my friends, the passion that intoxicates the universe and brings all of it alive. This is the radical creative act, an illogical one, and yet the only wise choice. For within each one of us, there is a very unique template, a very unique experiment of nature itself, waiting to see itself expressed. She speaks to us – sometimes in dreams, sometimes in impulses, sometimes in intuition, sometimes through chance meetings – yet it brings about the same effect when its a true impulse – radical aliveness. So I say pay attention to your whole body and the impulses that emerge from it, then follow it – this is what I mean by following your fascinations to where ever it will lead you. As I have mentioned what started as being fascinated with martial arts, opened new worlds, bought some of my best friends into life, got me to travel the world as though magically. Life suddenly goes from being disjoined to coherence, wholeness and consilence.”

fascinations

The student continued to listen to me with complete attention, and I could see something inside him had shifted, and he moved a little lighter. We continued driving through the redwood forests of Sequoia National Park for our training. We reached the bottom of the Morro Rock and we decided to race to the top of it. I slowly climbed up with one other student who was not in his best shape on that day. On reaching the top we had unprecedented views of the mountains and this student said to me “I feel I can see my homeland Mexico from here.” We laughed and sat down to enjoy the beauty. The student asked again “Sensei what else should i remember about this aliveness.” I paused a little, as though in deep thought, its amazing what the power of the pause can do, and the students waited on. I finally said “Where your attention goes so does your life, put your attention on what brings you alive. Its usually your fascinations that will bring you totally alive, and lead to what will seem like a magickal life, so put your attention over and over again on coming alive.”

The sunset was in progress and the sky came alive with a fiery shades of orange and red – it seemed like a painting. We were filled with joy and gratitude to be able to see this from over 9000 feet away from the madness of the city and reconnect with nature. As it got dark and we started climbing down slowly I remembered the Joseph Campbell quote and recited it for the students “If you follow your bliss, you put yourself on a kind of track that has been there all the while, waiting for you, and the life that you ought to be living is the one you are living. When you can see that, you begin to meet people who are in your field of bliss, and they open doors to you. I say, follow your bliss and don't be afraid, and doors will open where you didn't know they were going to be." I told them again, like I have numerous times before STUDY CAMPBELL, and if you don't have time to study him at least read this one book Reflections on The Art of Living. The students and I walked down and got into the car and were ready to drive back home, which is about 300 miles away now. As we drove away the question I always get when talking about following your fascinations finally showed by “but this is risky, there is no guarantee of success, I have responsibilities, what will society say, what if this does not work out?”  I remembered asking this exact same question to quite a few people including Paul Rebillot and Osho.

“Mahipal – Betrayal of the heart leads to decay, following it leads to a Heroic Journey. Life will always call you on an adventure, you have to follow it, if you dont – YOU SIMPLY ROT & DIE, your existence was wasted. So do not betray your heart. As my friend Alan Watts told once – better a short life in the direction of your heart than a long one being consumed inside out. So my child dont betray your heart, follow it. Dont fear the unknown, get curious about it. Leave the life you have to go to the life that is waiting for you to answer the call of adventure.”

Osho who always had a flair for jolting you into awakeness said something similar beautifully. “Never follow anybody else's idea -- that is very dangerous because you will become imitative. Always follow your own nature, self-nature; only then will you attain to freedom. It is better to die following one's nature than to live following somebody's else's nature, because that will be a pseudo life. To die following one's nature is beautiful, because that death too will be authentic.” Those words  of both Rebillot and Osho rung true deep inside me,and I shared them with the students and also my struggle when I betrayed the path. I recounted the 6 odd years when I had not heeded to the voice from deep within, and it wreak a havoc in my life, to the point where I was ready to kill myself (that story another time)  and the way out of the madness around me was to wake up to the aliveness and path again, and for me this was returning to my martial ways,  the way of the warrior. As I aligned myself back to it, magic happened again. I found myself training hard, Found Vilaire Sensei in California living with our dojo, RCG came into being, and I moved towards getting my Menkyo/license and dojos being set up in CA, South Dakota, Texas and Mexico City.

It was now time to drive back home after a heavy Mexican dinner in Three Rivers at the base of the redwood Forests, the three students were quite, two fell asleep while I was driving back home. It was well past 11 pm, and I had to be at work at 5 am the next day. In the silence of the night the same student finally said “you know Sensei, this makes a lot of sense, its like what Bruce Lee said - Always be yourself, express yourself, have faith in yourself, do not go out and look for a successful personality and duplicate it - its something like that yea?” A complete circle, back to martial arts, I laughed and remembered the times back in the day when I devoured everything Bruce did and said “something like that, something like that- forget what he said or what I say – listen to what your impulses say and come alive man, come alive the way only you can, that the best gift and legacy you can give yourself and to the world.”

I reached home at a little past 2 am, and took a short nap, and at 5 am it was time to be at work. After what seemed like a long day, wrapped up and it was time to be back at the dojo. A handful students including the two who spend the weekend training with me in the redwood forest showed up and as I got on the grass to teach and workout, all the tiredness was gone, and the aliveness returned, once again refreshed and ready to take on what shows up. Finished with the dojo and on the drive back home found myself humming these lines  I had written not too long ago

Ya Mere Khuda  / My lord, my highest self

Sunn Le Dil Ki Iltaaja  /Listen to my hearts deepest desire

Bande pe diwanigi aisi barsa  / Grant me the kind of passion

Jeete jeete ho jaye fanna  /That burns me like fire with every breath

And my wish to you is may you find that aliveness, that passion that burns deep inside!

- stream of consciousness writing to explain the guiding philosophy of Mt View Aiki Kai by Mahipal Lunia Sensei. These are his own personal views and do not represent the art or system or teacher/s

Nature & Self As Path and Destination

Nature & Self As Path and Destination

Lost

Stand still. The trees ahead

and bushes beside you

Are not lost. Wherever you are is called Here.

And you must treat it as a powerful stranger.

Must ask permission to know it and be known.

The forest breathes. Listen. It answers.

I have made this place around you.

If you leave it you may come back again.

saying Here.

No two trees are the same to Raven.

No two branches are the same to Wren.

If what a tree or a bush does is lost on you.

You art surely lost. Stand still.

The forest knows

Where you are. You must let it find you.

- An Old Native Indian Poem, translated by David Wagoner

After an exhausting day-long climb, we reached the top of Cloudsrest and marveled at the beauty of the Sierras while looking down on the iconic Half Dome. It was time for yet another shugyo deep in the backcountry of California’s famed Yosemite National Park. We put our 40 plus pound bags down, wiped the sweat of our brows, and found new energy from the beauty that surrounded and engulfed us. We experienced sheer silence, sheer presence, and a complete sense of belonging as we relaxed into our beings.

One of my students said, “This is so worth it—this view makes up for all of it. I am almost ready to cry.”  I told him to let go and let the tears roll, and forget yourself and fuse completely with nature all around. Later, as the sun set on the horizon and the temperatures dropped drastically, it struck me that “Nature and Self are both Path and Destination” and how much this has defined my own philosophy and how I teach my expression of the arts I have learnt from my teachers.

cloudsrest

There exist no conflicts or opposing principles in nature—the distinction of good and bad is a man-made context. And all conflict arises within this separation. There is no inherent conflict in nature itself. Later, cuddled up in my sleeping bag under the beautiful night sky, I remembered the reruns of Kung Fu with David Carradine that I had watched incessantly all through my childhood, waiting for my Master Kan. I was lucky to have not one, but a few. In one of the first episodes of Kung Fu, there is an iconic scene where Master Kan tells the young grasshopper, “In the Shaolin temple, there are three kinds of men: students, disciples, and masters. Development of the mind can be achieved only when the body has been disciplined. To accomplish this, the ancients have taught us to imitate God’s creatures. From the crane, we learn grace and self-control. The snake teaches us suppleness and rhythmic endurance. The praying mantis teaches us speed and patience. And from the tiger, we learn tenacity and power. And from the dragon, we learn to ride the wind. All creatures—the low and the high—are one with nature. If we have the wisdom to learn, all may teach us their virtues. Between the fragile beauty of the praying mantis and the fire and passion of the winged dragon, there is no discord. Between the supple silence of the snake and the eagle’s claws, there is only harmony. As no two elements of nature are in conflict, when we perceive the ways of nature, we remove conflict within ourselves and discover a harmony of body and mind in accord with the flow of the universe. It may take half a lifetime to master one system.” I fell asleep with a smile, thinking how wonderfully the threads of life weave themselves.

At the crack of dawn, I woke the three apprentices, as it was time to soak in the sun and train some more. Soaking in the beauty of the first rays of sun at 11,000 ft., I noticed my sense of Self had expanded far beyond my physical body and was zooming through space to merge with the rays of the sun itself. Frank Herbert, in his Dune Series, had brilliantly said, “Self is infinitely flexible, expanding to include desirable and useful others, and contracting to exclude the undesirable and harmful. Individually and collectively, how we fashion this entity determines the structure of the world we live in and the nature of the problems we must solve.” At this moment, it made perfect sense. And in those moments where everything is void, and therefore also possible, no limitations or problems appear. The samurai have long called this Mushin or ‘no-mind’ (which is a terrible term, but must suffice for now). This is the state of clarity every samurai warrior longed for in the battlefield and on the tatami mats. And yet, it is here, ready to be experienced. What is needed is a method to dial into it. More on a few techniques to dial into this state in future posts.

cloudsrest

We worked on the Katana (Japanese Blade/dagger) forms, and had the three apprentices take a portion of their test on the granite rocks of Sierras. Two hours in, we wrapped up and were ready to now begin the long descent down the mountain back to our cars parked deep down in Yosemite. One apprentice spoke up and said “This is so wonderful, but now its time to go back. I am sad.” I smiled, and explained to him that this beauty and sense of expansiveness is present everywhere—it’s not the domain of just the peaks/highs of life. This is how life is meant to be. It’s not just the destination/arrival that matters, but also how we arrive and depart from there.” He looked at me, half confused, but intently started walking down. After a few hours of silent walking interspersed by some discussions on Jesus, Osho, Bruce Lee, and our love lives, I bought the conversation back to the topic of path and destination.

“Nature and Self are both path and destination. Meaning, we use Nature and the body proper as the gateway to enter, traverse, and find that state of mushin/annyata/total fusion (martial arts/bhuddism/Tantra), which is ever present in Nature and the body proper. By learning to tune the body, in our case using the martial arts of Kaze, we are able to dial into that state where the I & Thou disappear—and something else entirely different emerges. It’s that something different that does the fighting when need be. It’s that something different that teaches when you are ready. And it’s that something different that dissolves all tensions and brings about a sense of complete calm.” I had my students complete, rapt attention as I continued, also somewhat surprised at my discovery and the words coming out of my mouth. David Whyte had once mentioned in a seminar, “Poetry is the art of saying things you did not know you knew.” I had experienced not only words, but entire forms of fighting emerge from that place in my body proper, much as my Senseis had told me years ago would happen.

I continued, “The body is the temple of the soul. Now, do you know what the word temple means? It comes from the word template—therefore, the really good question to ask is what is the body a template of?”  Seeing the confused looks, which I always love (as they are usually the beginning of something new ready to come in and take seat), I just continued walking away. This has taken years of practice to do, but always yields good results.  I wanted to leave them with the question, rather than a dogma or my truth.

A few days later, back in the dojo, the student walked up and said, “I felt peace in the mountains, and I want to go back there.” I told him there is no ‘there,’ and he needs to learn to have it here, as the body is the template of the universe itself, and in caring for the body proper and using it as both the path and destination, we arrive at that state of not leaving, wanting, or striving—and yet feeling fulfilled. It’s a hard task. I don’t claim to be able to do it all the time, and I train myself to take my body there every possible time—and hence, I show up at the dojo so often. Dojo—place of the way. Again, the place of the way to where? To the Self. As Herman Hesse so eloquently penned “every man is a path to himself.”

I closed the nested loop for my students, as I always do after a few weeks with this talk of “Nature and Self are both path and destination.” This is a foundational principle of how I specifically work with people at Mt. View Aiki Kai. This is my expression, my truth, and myself carving out my way. I want to close this piece with the words of the eminent mythologist Joseph Campbell, “ The goal of life is to make your heartbeat match the beat of the universe, to match your nature with Nature.” And our way of doing this is with the martial arts of Kaze, and using both Nature and Self as path and destination. If you do not understand this, you probably won’t follow much of what follows. You will remain a student, and never quite become a disciple/apprentice, leave alone attain mastery. The way to understand this is not an intellectual endeavor, but rather a deeply felt sense of path and destination becoming one, of Nature and Self fusing. And yet, as Master Kan had said in Kung Fu, “It may take years to understand.”

- stream of consciousness writing to explain the guiding philosophy of Mt. View Aiki Kai by Mahipal Lunia Sensei. These are his own personal views and do not represent the art/s,  system/s, or teacher/s he has studied with.

The Business of Art and The Art of Business And….

The Business of Art and The Art of Business And….

By Mahipal Lunia• January 8th, 2009 •

 

Andre: What does it do to us, Wally? Living in an environment where something as massive as the seasons or winter or cold, don’t in any way affect us? I mean, we're animals after all. I mean…what does that mean? I think that means that instead of living under the sun and the moon and the sky and the stars, we’re living in a fantasy world of our own making.
Wally: Yeah, but I mean, I would never give up my electric blanket, Andre. I mean, because New York is cold in the winter. I mean, our apartment is cold! It’s a difficult environment. I mean, our life is tough enough as it is. I’m not looking for ways to get rid of the few things that provide relief and comfort. I mean, on the contrary, I’m looking for more comfort because the world is very abrasive. I mean, I’m trying to protect myself because, really, there’s these abrasive beatings to be avoided everywhere you look!
Andre: But, Wally, don’t you see that comfort can be dangerous? I mean, you like to be comfortable, and I like to be comfortable too, but comfort can lull you into a dangerous tranquility.

Excerpt from “My Dinner With Andre” (1981)

It’s 5 PM. We start our quest this evening—the long drive from the South Bay to Berkeley, for a dinner with Antero Alli to discuss a movie project and pick his brain on what has worked for him in his projects. We have worked with Antero on two Paratheatre labs, participated in his AngelTechcourse, and recorded a series of talks/podcasts with him. As always, Sergey and I are discussing various things and laughing. Our latest fascination is a book called The Moon Of Hao Binh by William Pensinger. I tell him “Dude, I need a dictionary to read his book. And I need dictionaries in English, Japanese, and German.” Sergey asks me why I need three languages, to which I reply, “He has written the book using these three languages, with doses of Vietnamese.” Sergey laughs and mockingly says, “Who the hell writes one book using three different languages?” I respond, “Pensinger does, he is apparently doing his thing his way. I don’t think he cares whether the world reads his work or not.”

We arrive at Himalaya—a Nepalese restaurant in Berkeley—at about 7 PM, and are seated by the hostess after a warm Namaste. The menu is rich, and we order chicken tikka, ghosht haiyali (lamb), bhindi tarkari (okra), and of course Naan with mango chutney on the side. Antero is seated in front of me, and Sergey to my right. As we settle into our seats and the conversation is about to begin, I think to myself, “This will surely be an interesting evening, and discussion will range from Paratheatre, to movies, to the business of movie making, and who knows what else.”

I can’t help but think to myself that this scene, this location, and perhaps even the range of topics seems eerily similar to the movie “My Dinner With Andre (1980).” For those of you who have not seen the movie, we highly recommend this movie of two friends talking over dinner in a New York restaurant. The movie—for those who have not seen it—revolves around two key themes from the path breaking work of Jerzy Grotowski. The two themes are:

1. Living spontaneously by following one’s impulses and

2. What is the purpose and nature of theater

The restaurant is half-packed with guests all around, and quickly our focus begins to crystallize around our table and the discussion to unfold. After two Paratheatre labs (watch for three podcasts on this topic coming soon, titled “Beware Archetypes Crossing”) each lasting between eight and ten, meeting twice a week for three hours, it’s time to get some feedback and pointers to further development in this medium as we prepare for our third lab with him. Antero tells me to give myself more time in no-form. My mind quickly races and remembers trying to articulate what no-form is to a friend, before guiding him to Antero’s own description on his website. In Antero’s own words, “The purpose of no-form is two-fold: 1) To deepen receptivity to energy sources innate to the physical and energetic bodies towards their engagement and expression and 2) To discharge and disperse identification with these forces after each engagement. Like an empty container, no-form allows us to become full with the energies engaged and then to empty again. No-form is not something that can be taught, but only developed and deepened—we either already have some existing relationship or intimacy with the Void, or we do not. The experience is essentially personal to each individual, but, also, impersonal. Astrophysics suggests there is no such thing as ‘empty space’ anywhere in nature, that space is not empty, but teeming with dynamic potential energy. They could have been describing no-form. 

We moved on to discuss how Sergey works with his voice. Sergey has been working on unfolding his voice and discovering what else he can do. The discussion moved to how the quality of the voice changes based on which cavity we explore voice from. The quality of the voice changes so much based on whether it comes from the nose, the throat, the chest, or the diaphragm. Antero concluded this part saying, “Explore your voice coming and going deep into different cavities and, see what emerges.” And the ever-esoteric, and yet so much in the body, “Move the voice through the body, through the muscles. Voice is energy. It is vibration. It has an effect. Explore it.” There is the same theme again, “Don’t go meta, go meso. Truth is here, in the body and the world. It is not out there, outside of the body and the world.”

The food arrived, its aroma filled the room, and we started to dig into the delicacies that lay before us. The paintings of various gods, the large wall painted with Mt. Meru, and the sweet smells of various spices was a feast for our consciousness. The imagery of Mt. Meru bought the conversation now to the work of Alejandro Jodorowsky and his movie “The Holy Mountain.” The conversation was now quickly moving towards our work—the work of creating a movie/documentary with Bucky’s principles.  Buckminister Fuller’s (Bucky's) ideas and generalized principles have had a huge impact on us, and we are looking at ways of exploring them in a  new format.

Our discussion went all over, with Antero sharing his directorial experiences and how to make movies. The themes revolved around picking the main theme, scouting the locations, nesting multiple stories vs. one story, etc. This has given us a lot of food for thought. As the main course comes to an end, and many of the tables that were once filled are now emptying, our ideas/thoughts race at 100 miles an hour. I ask, “How do we draw a balance between what we want to say and what the audience will understand? Do we make the movie such that the largest possible audience gets the ideas, such that these seeds are planted into their consciousness?”

The hostess now approaches us, and brings us the check. I looked at her, and think to myself, “We are not done.” I ask if could we please get some chai for all of us. A good Indian meal is never complete without chai. Indian chai—when made right—has just this right blend of sweetness and spiciness, coming from a mixture of cardamom, ginger, and cinnamon, among other spices. The whole approach of the hostess again brought to mind “My dinner with Andre,” with the occasional intrusion of the waiter during the dinner, and—more importantly—a rich conversation. The chai arrived, and the aroma filled my consciousness while the warmth of the drink soothed my throat.

There are some that consider the audience, and tailor the movie towards them,” continued Antero as we sipped our delicious chai. “But if that formula works, then there would be so many more hits and blockbusters.” We just rolled in laughter at the obviousness and irony of the statement. He summed his take on this: “Stay true to your vision, plan hard on what you want to do, and be prepared for improvisations to happen and emerge.” Our discussion went on for a while longer on various topics on making movies, staying true to one’s vision, and letting improvisations emerge. The hostess arrived once again with the check, and after paying it, we started our walk back towards Antero’s home. It’s about 10 PM now, I think, and most business around Shattuck Avenue have shut down for the night

Its past 10:15 pm or so, and it will be at least an hour’s drive home. We say our goodbyes for now, ending with a “See you at the lab in March.” We get into Sergey’s car—our very faithful companion on many trips of exploration—and start our drive back to the south bay. The hour is filled with lively discussion of things we learned, and the path that lay before us. Sergey stated, “You know, the thing that stood out for me is we need to focus on the imperfections of the characters. The screw-ups in their lives will actually add to the richness of the story. If you notice the development and growth of RCG, we have been opening up to our faults more and more, being more vulnerable to who we are, and how we may be screwed up.” I nodded, and said, “Yes, I agree. Our path from our faults and short comings towards some sense of normalcy and contribution is the true hero’s journey. As Antero had said earlier, “Don’t build superheroes.” Look in the ordinary and find the extraordinary.

A little past 11, when I get home, the same thought keeps running through me: “Stay true to your art, your vision.” It’s a cold night, I pull my comforter on me and think yes, it’s important to stay true to our art, our vision. After all, that’s what we are doing with RCG. We have not advertised and have not commercialized. We have done it as an expression, as an offering. It was for the sake of following our vision, our art—not for commercial value. And yet, it seems to have touched listeners around the planet, and brought many wonderful people into our lives. Yes, staying true to one’s vision, one’s art, and one’s impulses—even if you are on the fringe, even if it makes you a deviant—is critical. The goal here is truly to make sure you are a positive deviant

All ideas follow the same path. They start with the artist/idealist on the fringe, and then move into the cutting edge, where a few others have seen and communicate the same vision. From here, if it catches the eye of the hipsters, it enters the realm of the cool in the hip circles until a “tipping point” arrives, taking it towards the next big thing. It ends up becoming a social convention. The art and artist stays pure to his vision, and is found in the fringe and cutting edge. As more enter it, the devox “voice of the deviant” starts to be lost, the business of art starts to fade, and the art of business kicks in.

The Art of Business is taking the ideas from the cutting edge and realm of the cool,  moving it into “the next big thing,” and hoping that this expression becomes a social convention. In making it a social convention, huge fortunes are made—usually for the venture capitalist and acute entrepreneur. They have usually moved away, if not far away, from the devox—the true voice of the original deviant, who perhaps sits and sees that his art is now perhaps a shadow of the original. It hits me, as I roll in bed, that perhaps this is what James Joyce was alluding to in his “Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man” where he speaks of the function of art. Joyce states that the “true art is beautiful and/or sublime. It stops you dead in your tracks, leaves you speechless.” He further states what art is not: “Improper art moves you to do something. It either aims to teach or move you to do something that you would not normally do.” It hits me that is the aim of advertising—the critical tool to move an idea/vision from the cutting edge to the next big thing. It aims at making you do something you would not normally do or want.

The Business of Art is following one’s impulses to find beauty and the sublime in it, and to be arrested in its awe. The Art of Business is “moving others to do something they may not normally do.” There has to be a third way… there must be a third way. But, for now, I need to sleep. I have a long day ahead and must be at work at 6 am. For now, I tell myself, “Stay true to your art, your vision,” and cuddle into the warmth of my comforter.

The next day, after a long day at work, between partnership meetings and meetings, I return home. My mind is still reeling from the conversations the night before and the Business of Art. Bucky and the movie to get his ideas out have somehow taken the back seat. I continue reading the Moon of Hao Bihn until its time to head to the dojo. The evening is cold, and it sure gets dark early in winters. The dojo, or where the way is practiced, is a corner in the park. The class is small—four regular students and me. This evening, there are only two shows. It hits me—even though there are just two students and me, we are here when it’s wet and cold, practicing our art. We are following our impulses to learn the martial art that has been passed down from generation to generation for perhaps hundreds of years, and in the process, discovering ourselves.

This evening in the dojo with two students reminds me of my days with my sensei, and the small one room dojo. Sensei had converted the small living room into our dojo. The matted room measured approximately 15 feet wide and about 25 feet in length. Sensei had given up a lot—including promotions on his job, and perhaps much more—in order to be true to his art, his form of expressing his spirit. Like clockwork, he would be there every evening, teaching the next generation of practitioners the art, spirit, and way of the warrior. Sastri Sensei left his family behind, country, and home in order to follow his impulse and introduce the art (to which he had dedicated many, many years) to another generation, in another part of the world. A group of us would practice with him every opportunity we got for hours on end. I remember clearly him one night telling us, “You are young, and you can be a hundred other places on this Friday night. Yet here you are, giving and receiving pain. This will be rewarded, in ways you cannot conceive yet. You know you are like the young piano player, who is practicing and practicing while his friends play. A day will soon come, when the young maestro will play, and his friends will pay to watch. Stick with it, stick with the practice and dedication to the art, and it will reward you in ways you don’t yet know.”

So. Here I am, sitting. That feeling of calm comes back, and I know that, for me, it is the “continuation of being true to the art and expression” of my spirit, of my own way. The movie, the podcasts, and the dojo all serve the same need—they are devices for reaching into the further expanses of my own inner space. Time to head to bed, this time more relaxed. I tell myself the third way: “Art is the way.” It’s not about the Business of Art or Art of Business, but Art is the way. And the way of Art is “following those impulses from deep within,” and then continuing to work on the Art while others play. When it is your turn to play, they will pay to be there.  Time to sleep, and tomorrow it will be time again to work on the art, while others perhaps are playing.

Mahipal Lunia

, , , , , ,